Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Enforcement Detainment Definition topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Committee introduces RS 32,052 with tightened language on enforcement tied to independent crimes
Summary
Representative Jaren Crane introduced RS 32,052 (related to a prior draft that became House Bill 11) and described changes negotiated with trial‑lawyers and dairy‑industry stakeholders to narrow enforcement language so officers may act only when an independent crime under Title 18, Idaho Code, is the basis for detention or investigation.
Representative Jaren Crane (District 12) presented RS 32,052 and described edits the sponsor and a cosponsor made after meeting with trial‑lawyers and representatives of the dairy industry. Crane said the RS language was tightened to make clear law enforcement may enforce the section only "when a person is detained or investigated for suspected commission of an independent crime under Title 18, Idaho Code."
Crane told the committee the changes came from stakeholders who wanted to ensure that the statute would not permit an officer to demand papers in the absence of a criminal basis for detention. He said the word "crime" will appear consistently in the draft and that his cosponsor, a retired attorney, would address the difference between infractions and crimes in a fuller hearing.
Representative Barbieri voiced support for the tightened language on Fourth Amendment grounds, saying she did not want law enforcement to be able to ask for identification without a proper criminal basis. Following brief discussion the committee voted by voice to introduce RS 32,052 for printed hearing.
The RS references enforcement tied to Title 18, Idaho Code and indicates stakeholders (trial lawyers and the Dairymen's group) participated in drafting amendments. The committee recorded no roll‑call tally; the motion to introduce carried by voice vote.
