Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Domestic Violence Policy topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Committee rejects elevating second domestic-violence conviction to felony after heated debate
Summary
Senator Hill proposed raising a second domestic-violence conviction to a felony and adding a 24–48-hour "cooling-off" hold and GPS monitoring; supporters said the changes would protect victims, opponents warned about over‑criminalizing misdemeanors. The committee failed to pass the measure (4 in favor, 6 opposed).
Senator Hill presented a committee substitute for Senate Bill 2191 that would elevate a second conviction of domestic violence from a misdemeanor to a felony and add related bond and monitoring conditions.
"This bill only does 1 thing. It elevates a second offense of domestic violence, a second conviction to a felony," Senator Hill said, noting Parole Board members and the Mississippi Domestic Violence Coalition supported the change as a deterrent.
Senator Boyd's language in the committee substitute added two main elements: a short "cooling off" detention not to exceed 48 hours (with a minimum of 24 hours), and a requirement for GPS monitoring for certain offenses. Senate staff explained that section 99538 would be amended to require wearing a GPS monitor in specified cases; sponsors said the monitoring would help enforce protection orders and detect violations.
Opponents, including public defenders and municipal-court practitioners, argued the proposal risked turning routine or nonviolent domestic incidents — often charged as simple assault because the statute covers acts that put a person in fear — into felonies.
Senator Sparks said many municipal and justice-court cases arise from disputes that "do not rise to the level of a felony" and cautioned against criminalizing verbal disputes or nonviolent incidents. Senator Wiggins and others said the underlying problem required broader interventions, such as attention to strangulation and domestic-violence prevention, rather than simply elevating penalties.
Senator Hill and supporters argued the bill would slow repeat offenders from cycling through municipal court and would provide tools (bond conditions and monitoring) to protect victims; Hill urged committee members to continue refining the language and to keep the measure moving.
Committee action: members counted hands after a motion to report the committee substitute. The clerk recorded 4 hands in favor and 6 opposed. The chair announced the bill did not pass the committee.
