Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Urban Forestry And Parks topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
City staff to recheck North Beach Oceanside Park tree losses; 90-day report and pilot replanting planned
Summary
City staff will reinspect North Beach Oceanside Park tree plantings and return in 90 days with an updated condition report; staff also proposed a phased pilot replanting using protective sea grape and silver buttonwood barriers and testing up to five additional native species as part of the Geo Bond reforestation effort.
Urban forestry staff told the committee that of the 376 trees installed under the relevant permit for the North Beach Oceanside Park beach walk, staff records show a survival calculation of about 300 of 376 (cited as roughly 80 percent) but that many trees are stressed or defoliated.
Lindsey Pratt, Assistant Director of the Environment and Sustainability Department, reported staff removed multiple dead trees in prior inspections (staff cited two earlier removal events of 38 trees each and an additional removal of 13 trees in a later inspection). She said the coastal microclimate (direct salt spray, exposure, dune elevation and wind tunnel effects) has produced widespread defoliation; staff reported approximately 180 trees currently defoliated with approximately 70 percent leaf loss, and identified 76 as dead or removed in prior counts.
Staff outlined follow-up steps: a reinspection at the end of the dry season (May–June), a 90‑day status update to this committee, and an LTC/report after the next inspection. Urban forestry recommended planting protective species (sea grapes and silver buttonwood) as windbreaks and “clumping” less-hardy species, longer establishment watering periods for new plantings, and testing smaller/younger stock that can acclimate. The committee asked for a pilot program to test up to five native tree species in select beach‑adjacent city-owned locations, to be coordinated with the Geo Bond reforestation project; staff said that pilot plantings could be included in the Geo Bond work and that the work will likely take longer than 90 days to show definitive success, but that an interim status update in 90 days is appropriate.
Commissioners and members of the public urged caution about large-scale plantings without site-specific testing; some commissioners stressed that sea grapes performed well historically and urged restoring previously removed mature vegetation where feasible. Staff agreed to return with a 90‑day condition report and to include a plan for a phased, monitored reforestation pilot and warranty considerations for future contracts.
The committee also asked for a brief LTC with capital cost figures for the original planting (staff said capital costs would be pulled from project records) and for the parks and urban forestry teams to coordinate community outreach and the Geo Bond reforestation schedule.
