Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Library Expansion topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Council approves Highland Park Public Library expansion, rezoning and parking exception after split vote
Summary
The council approved rezoning, a final plat and a special-use permit to allow a 7,850-square-foot library addition and granted a 40-space parking exception; the measures passed 5-2 after debate over loss of green space and process concerns.
The Highland Park City Council voted 5-2 on Jan. 27 to approve a package of measures allowing the Highland Park Public Library to expand: rezoning several parcels to the PA (public activity) district, approving a final plat of subdivision, and granting a special-use permit and a special exception for parking relief that reduces the library—s required on-site parking by 40 spaces. Councilmembers Tapia and Littler voted no.
Director of Community Development Veil Fontaine summarized staff and plan-commission review. The proposed addition is about 7,850 square feet, with a maximum height of 32.5 feet. The plan includes extensive landscaping; staff said the proposal provides a surplus of shrubs and trees relative to code requirements. The project would keep extensive pathways and retain significant plantings along St. John—s Avenue.
The library had requested a rezoning to make library use a permitted use in the district; staff and the Plan and Design Commission recommended approval. The commission voted in favor of the rezoning and special use recommendation (6-0 and 5-0-1 for parking relief, per the staff report) and recommended certain conditions including lighting restrictions and easements for relocated utilities.
Council discussion focused on trade-offs between expanding library services and preserving the open green lawn west of the library. Several councilmembers, including Annette Littler and Councilmember Tapia, expressed disappointment at the loss of the front lawn and concerns about the process and the degree of review for adjacent issues (for example, the future of the Miss Nitro sculpture and other campus elements). Councilmember Tony Bloomberg and others said staff and the library board had thoroughly examined alternatives, including building up or expanding east, and concluded those options were prohibitively costly or technically infeasible; Bloomberg said the board had been fiscally cautious in planning.
Library advocates and some councilmembers stressed the community value of expanded children—s services and programming. Councilmember Barissa Brockman and others described strong public demand for youth services; staff noted the library is one of the community—s most-used public buildings. Opponents in the audience urged the council to slow the process and consider a broader holistic plan for the campus; resident Jason Dreyfus called for pausing the approvals and argued for more attention to the sculpture and green-space impacts.
After debate, the council adopted the rezoning, plat and special-use actions and granted the parking exception to allow the expansion. Staff said a final plat amendment will be recorded to reflect municipal approval and that the applicant must satisfy the plan-commission conditions, secure required easements and follow the city engineer's direction on relocated utilities.
Vote tally: Barissa Brockman — aye; Yumi Ross — aye; Councilmember Tapia — no; Annette Littler — no; Kim Stone — aye; Tony Bloomberg — aye; Mayor Nancy Rotering — aye. The package passed, 5 ayes to 2 nays.
