Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Digital Content topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Trustees warned that ebook licensing changes by major publishers will raise costs, limit access
Summary
Library leaders described recent changes by major publishers (Macmillan, Penguin Random House, Simon & Schuster and others) that replace perpetual e‑book/audiobook ownership with time-limited or metered licenses; the board discussed higher long-term costs and possible organized responses.
Library staff told the Board of Library Trustees that changes in digital-license models by major trade publishers are reducing libraries' access to newly released ebooks and audiobooks, increasing costs and potentially limiting immediate access for low-income readers.
Michael Blackwell, director of the St. Mary's County Library, outlined a string of publisher policy changes since 2018: Tor (a Macmillan imprint) imposed a 120-day ebook embargo in July 2018; Penguin Random House moved from perpetual single-copy licenses to metered two-year/52-circ licenses in October 2018; other publishers have replaced perpetual ownership with time-limited access for ebooks and digital audiobooks. Blackwell said Simon & Schuster converted digital audiobooks to two‑year access and that Macmillan has offered a single perpetual copy for the first eight weeks of a new release before the title moves to expiring licenses.
"What this means is fewer options for libraries and higher costs over time," Blackwell said, adding that metered or expiring licenses can multiply the cost of providing the same title over multiple years. He described the change as a systemic shift in how libraries obtain digital content: unlike a print book that libraries own under the first‑sale doctrine, licensed digital content is controlled by publishers and can return to the market in ways libraries cannot manage.
Blackwell said the St. Mary's system participates in statewide consortia and has already felt the effect: when the publisher limits a perpetual copy at statewide level, library patrons may face long waits for new releases. He said national library organizations are organizing responses; the American Library Association (ALA) has relaunched a digital content working group and some libraries are considering coordinated boycotts or legal and advocacy strategies. "The publishers' primary motivation is profit," Blackwell said. "We're worried about providing digital content in the future as that becomes increasingly the mode in which people expect to get content."
Trustees and staff discussed consequences: greater demand for recent popular titles may force libraries to prioritize purchases, reducing budget available for nonfiction and research materials. The board noted that national coverage of the dispute has begun, and Blackwell referenced local media coverage that has brought attention to the issue.
No formal vote or policy change was taken at the meeting; trustees asked staff to continue monitoring publisher negotiations and report back as national responses evolve.
