Marshfield Utilities commission denies vehicle-damage claim from Timothy Hovindik

The Marshfield Utilities Commission on a split vote denied an insurance claim by resident Timothy Hovindik for damage his vehicle sustained after driving off a concrete driveway entrance at the former water office at 1210 South Oak Avenue.

The commission heard staff explain that the utility's insurer investigated and found no negligence by Marshfield Utilities and that the insurer had formally disallowed the claim. Staff recommended the commission deny the claim, which would shorten the statute of limitations to six months if the claimant pursued the matter further.

Commissioners discussed site conditions and prior maintenance. A staff member said crews initially filled a pothole at the driveway, but the depression reappeared; an on-site inspection found vehicle traffic crossing a narrow driveway and adjacent grass, which contributed to the recurring problem. The commission noted a temporary cone was placed and that staff plans to address the area with a more stable foundation in summer.

A motion to deny the claim was made and seconded. In a roll-call vote recorded in the meeting transcript, Commissioners Dobkins, Peschel, Folke and Eberl and the chair voted in favor; no opposing votes were recorded. The motion carried and the claim was denied.

The commission’s minutes note staff will proceed consistent with the insurer’s denial and with statutory timelines. No further financial action by the utility was reported at the meeting.