Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Superintendent Search topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Paradise Valley board hires Arizona School Administrators for superintendent search after debate
Summary
After extended debate about procurement, the Paradise Valley Unified School District Governing Board voted 4–1 to retain the Arizona School Administrators (ASA) to conduct a national superintendent search under an agreement not to exceed $10,000.
The Paradise Valley Unified School District Governing Board voted 4–1 to retain the Arizona School Administrators Association to conduct the district's superintendent search, approving an Executive Search Services Agreement that the district said will cost $8,000 plus expenses (not to exceed $10,000).
Board members spent more than three hours discussing procurement history, vendor experience and timeline before the vote. The item moved from discussion into a motion after members debated whether to reopen requests-for-qualifications (RFQs) and solicit additional vendors. "We're here to help you be successful," said Dr. Tim Ogle, representing the Arizona School Administrators Association, during his presentation to the board.
Supporters said ASA offers Arizona-based consultants with national recruitment reach and a lower price than the major national search firms the district considered in a prior review. Dr. Ogle described a six-phase search process that includes community engagement, confidential screening in executive session and finalist visits; he said the association routinely recruits nationally through a network of state associations.
Opponents, led by Governing Board Member Mrs. Christiansen, urged more transparent procurement and argued the board should compare ASA against other firms with longer commercial search track records. Christiansen moved to table the item and reopen RFQs. That motion failed 4–1, and the board then approved ASA's agreement by the same margin.
Superintendent Tim Reynolds and other staff described ASA as a nonprofit membership organization that provides search services at members' request; the board heard that ASA consultants are former Arizona superintendents. The board and Dr. Ogle discussed a compressed timeline if the board wants a superintendent in place by the district's target date; Ogle said the usual marketplace runs from late fall through spring and that an accelerated schedule is possible but reduces lead time for recruiting.
The board directed staff and the search consultant to proceed under the approved contract. The motion as approved gives the board the option to accept ASA's services after presentation and does not bind the board to a hire until the formal finalist and contract steps occur.
