Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Surveillance topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Commission delays decision on city ‘lock camera’ surveillance system until Nov. 17 amid pending lawsuits
Summary
Commissioners voted to postpone a decision on installing a citywide camera system after members raised concerns about pending litigation in other jurisdictions and Freedom of Information Act implications; city staff and the attorney said policy language and FOIA interactions are under review.
The City Commission voted Oct. 6 to postpone action on a proposed citywide lock‑camera system until its second meeting in November (scheduled for Nov. 17), saying pending lawsuits elsewhere could affect the city’s legal exposure.
Commissioner Petrie moved to delay consideration “until the lawsuit that's pending right now in Norfolk, Virginia, and there's another one in Washington, till those are settled,” citing concerns about similar litigation involving camera systems. The motion to postpone was seconded and, after discussion about timing, the commission set Nov. 17 as the date to revisit the item.
Commissioners and staff discussed whether a city policy governing release of footage would affect legal risk. Staff said the proposed policy had been reviewed with the city attorney and that the policy language was designed to be similar to lien policies that are not subject to FOIA; the city attorney cautioned that court rulings in other jurisdictions have found public‑records laws require release of footage in some situations.
Some commissioners urged caution, saying court cases can take years and recommending the city adopt clear ordinance or policy language before finalizing camera purchases or operations. Others noted many jurisdictions already operate camera systems and that the legal risk is not unique to Lapeer.
The motion to postpone until Nov. 17 passed by voice vote.
