HDC approves matte 'White Dove' paint for 87 Main after planner recommends subdued historic white

The Nantucket Historic District Commission on Oct. 21 approved an applicant's request to repaint 87 Main Street from historic yellow to a historic white, with commissioners and the preservation planner specifying a matte, "earth tone" white.

Applicant Nina Ross said she sought permission "to change it to historic white." Preservation planner Holly (preservation planner) told the commission the house is an 1830–34 Charles Clark and Sarah Gardner Clerk House and that historic whites historically had a softer, slightly brownish-gray cast because they contained lead-based pigments. Holly recommended "an earth tone white" and said a low-sheen finish would be appropriate for the building's age and character.

Commissioners agreed. Commissioner Angus McLeod moved approval with the condition that the final paint be a matte Benjamin Moore White Dove and that the finish not be glossy. Commissioner Angus McLeod noted he had reviewed the application for consent and preferred that Holly—who had local historical expertise—work with the applicant on the precise selection. Commissioner Val Oliver added she "think[s] we have to take the color seriously because it's a historic house," and Commissioner Connie Patton and Commissioner Joe Paul voted in favor.

The commission also discussed shutters and trim: Ross confirmed shutters would remain Essex green as submitted. Holly recommended avoiding glossy paint and referenced a previous approval on 15 Fair Street for a similar historic white. The COA (certificate of appropriateness) language adopted at the meeting specified White Dove in a matte finish, with Holly to confirm final swatch placement.

The decision was approved by roll call: Angus McLeod, Connie Patton, Joe Paul and Val Oliver voted aye.

Looking ahead, Holly asked staff to record the approved swatch and finish on the permit so future repaints match the chosen, historically appropriate tone.