Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the School Safety topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Resident raises safety and billing questions at Village of Manhattan public comments
Summary
Paula Gibbs, a local plumber, urged the board to note potential safety disparities between St. Joseph’s School (required to have sprinklers) and public school trailers that lack sprinklers; she also asked about a $43,000 dewatering bill and several solar-permit charges.
Paula Gibbs, a Manhattan resident and local 130 plumber, used the meeting’s public-comment period to raise safety concerns and ask for clarification about bills listed on the village bills list.
Gibbs said she had followed the previous meeting’s discussion about St. Joseph’s and wanted to record a public concern that public school trailers — which she said house some Manhattan students — lack sprinkler systems while St. Joseph’s Catholic School is being required to install sprinklers. “These are our Manhattan kids,” Gibbs said, and she urged that the discrepancy be recorded in the minutes so parents and the public are aware of the difference in standards. Gibbs said Mark Nelson had told the board that the Regional Board of Education is the authority on school standards.
Gibbs also asked about two financial items on the bills list. She asked about a line described as dewatering biosolids for $43,000, saying, “That’s a lot for dewatering,” and asked whether there was a contract or special circumstance justifying the amount. A staff member responded that the item was “by public works” and the meeting host said public works staff could prepare an answer after the meeting, either in writing or in person.
She further asked about charges related to eight residential solar-panel permits, asking why the village is paying for them. Staff clarified that the village is not paying residents; the bills reflect permit and inspection fees that residents pay when they apply for roof-mounted solar systems, and the speaker noted permit-review and structural inspection costs and typical permit fees in the $300–$350 range.
Gibbs said an RPZ (reduced pressure zone) device for water protection would itself cost “8 to 10,000,” and that she did not believe a previously cited $30,000 estimate for a St. Joseph’s project captured the full scope. She identified herself as a local 130 plumber with about 20 years’ experience and said her estimating experience informed her comment.
The board did not take action on Gibbs’s requests during the meeting; staff offered to follow up with written answers after the meeting.
