Senator Lakey presents draft Idaho Right to Farm Act; committee votes to print RS32027
Loading...
Summary
Sen. Todd Lakey presented RS32027, a proposed amendment to Idaho Right to Farm law designed to let prevailing, lawfully operating agricultural producers recover attorney fees and to penalize repeated meritless complaints; committee voted to print the RS for further drafting.
Senator Todd Lakey, a state senator from District 23, presented RS32027 to the Idaho Senate Agricultural Affairs Committee, proposing changes to Idaho's Right to Farm law intended to add practical protections for lawfully operating agricultural producers. "It's not a shield for bad operators, it's a protection for good operators," Lakey told the committee, describing the bill's purpose.
Lakey said RS32027 would allow a lawfully operating farmer who prevails in a nuisance lawsuit to recover attorney fees from the nonprevailing party and would create escalating penalties for repeated meritless complaints filed with state agencies or local authorities. "If they file a second complaint that's meritless within a 2 year rolling window, then it's an infraction, and there's a hundred and $50 fine. If they file a third meritless complaint within that 2 year period, then it's still an infraction, but it's a $300 fine. And then if they file a fourth and subsequent complaint within that 2 year period it becomes a misdemeanor," Lakey said.
Committee members asked how "meritless" would be determined and whether the problem of being dragged into court despite prevailing was increasing. Lakey directed members to language in the draft that defines meritless complaints and said investigating agencies would determine whether a complaint lacks merit; if an infraction is pursued the court would ultimately decide. He also told the committee he had not tracked case counts and could not say whether nuisance suits were increasing, though he said growth in rural residential development raises concern and the proposal aims to provide both deterrence and some cost relief for prevailing farmers.
After Lakey's presentation the committee moved and seconded a motion to print RS32027 for drafting and filing with the Legislature. The motion carried; the committee did not take public testimony on the RS during this session.
The proposal as presented focuses on (1) attorney-fee recovery for agricultural operators who prevail in nuisance litigation under Idaho's Right to Farm protections and (2) escalating sanctions for repeated meritless complaints to agencies such as the Idaho State Department of Agriculture, Department of Environmental Quality and Department of Lands, and to local or state law enforcement. The draft as presented preserves that complaints may still be investigated and adjudicated and does not change the underlying statutory standards for what constitutes a lawful agricultural operation.
The committee vote to print RS32027 sends the draft to the legislative counsel for formal bill drafting and to the Senate schedule for future consideration.
