Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Public Health Districts topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Senate committee approves printing of RS31856 to limit public health districts’ broad authority
Summary
The Idaho Senate Health & Welfare Committee voted to print RS31856, a measure sponsored by Senator Brian Lenny that would add new accountability requirements and require public health actions be grounded in science, the sponsor said. Committee members asked for clearer definitions of terms such as “broad” and “arbitrary.”
The Idaho Senate Health & Welfare Committee voted to send RS31856 to print after a brief floor-level exchange about the proposal’s scope and consequences.
Senator Brian Lenny, District 13 representing Nampa, introduced RS31856 as a response to lessons learned during the COVID-19 pandemic and said the measure would “tighten the rein on our public health districts by adding a layer of accountability” and ensure that “any health action taken is backed by solid…science.”
The resolution would limit the broad authority currently granted to public health districts, which Lenny described as a statutory grant that allows districts to “do all things.” Senator Melissa Wintrow asked whether Lenny had consulted local public health boards and other stakeholders and requested clearer definitions for language in the draft, specifically what it would mean to prohibit the health boards from “engag[ing] in broad or arbitrary actions.” Wintrow said lawmakers will need answers about “who decides on what’s broad and how you define arbitrary.”
Lenny replied that he expected to address those details at a full hearing and described the move as “just knocking them down a peg and adding what I believe is a layer of accountability.” He said the measure is intended to discourage “guesswork, knee jerk reactions, or excessive measures” by public health boards.
Senator Mark Harris moved to send RS31856 to print; Senator Greg Bierke seconded. The committee approved the motion by voice vote with no opposition recorded.
Committee members indicated a full hearing will follow once the resolution is printed, where proponents, opponents and subject-matter experts can provide additional detail and the committee can consider statutory language, definitions and stakeholder input.
Votes at the meeting on RS31856 were voice votes; no roll-call tallies were taken during the committee session.
What’s next: RS31856 will be printed and scheduled for a full committee hearing, where the sponsor said he will address the technical questions raised by members about definitions and stakeholder consultation.
