Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Appropriations Law topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Legislative counsel briefs committee on the constitutional basis and statutory rules for appropriations and JFAC authority
Summary
Legislative legal counsel reviewed the constitutional origins of the legislature's appropriation power, key Idaho constitutional limits (balanced-budget requirement, item veto rules, prohibition on sectarian appropriations) and the statutes that define JFAC's duties and the budget process.
Elizabeth Bowen, legislative legal counsel at the Legislative Services Office, briefed the Joint Finance-Appropriations Committee on the legal framework that underpins appropriation authority and the committee's duties.
Bowen began with constitutional foundations, noting the legislature's "power of the purse" flows from the republican structure embedded in the U.S. and state constitutions and that appropriations "can be withdrawn from the state treasury only pursuant to an appropriation made by law" (she cited Article 7, Section 13 of the Idaho Constitution). She described appropriation statutes as ordinary laws of equal standing and cited a judicial definition: appropriations are authority given by the legislature in legal form to pay a specified sum for a specified purpose.
Limits and procedures Bowen highlighted include the state constitutional balanced-budget provision (Article 7, Section 11), the governor's item-veto power (which can be used to strike dollar amounts in appropriation bills but not conditions attached to appropriations), and the prohibition against sectarian appropriations (Article 9, Section 5). She also explained the constitutional requirements that bills have a single subject and an enacting clause and that amendatory acts must reproduce the statute text being amended.
Statutory duties of JFAC Bowen walked through the statutes that create and empower JFAC (Idaho Code Chapter 4 Title 67 and the related budget chapters in Title 67). She cited code sections authorizing JFAC to review executive and agency budgets, hold hearings, draft appropriation bills, create interim subcommittees, inspect records, and issue subpoenas if needed. Bowen noted that JFAC drafts appropriation bills and that the appropriation may include conditions, limitations and restrictions the legislature places on the use of appropriated funds; those conditions are binding.
Account categories and transfers Bowen summarized that appropriations are made by account categories (personnel, operating, capital outlay, trustee and benefit payments) and cannot be moved between account categories without following transfer rules; transfers greater than 10% generally require legislative approval. She outlined the role of the board of examiners and executive adjustments for carry-forward or executive carry forward authorities.
Why it matters: Bowen emphasized that understanding the constitutional and statutory guardrails is necessary for JFAC to exercise its authority over appropriations, to attach lawful conditions, and to review requests for supplemental appropriations, transfers, or reorganizations.
Next steps: Bowen offered to answer committee questions and said statutory citations and details in the presentation can guide drafters as the committee prepares appropriation language.
