Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Public Comment Civility topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Residents press El Segundo council over Hispanic Heritage Month presentation and councilmember remarks
Summary
Multiple residents urged the City Council to acknowledge harm from an earlier meeting’s handling of a Hispanic Heritage Month presentation and criticized councilmember conduct; several council members apologized or clarified remarks.
Several residents used the Oct. 21 public‑comment period to press the El Segundo City Council to respond to events tied to a recent Hispanic Heritage Month presentation and to criticize the tone of council debate at the Oct. 7 meeting.
John Piccaber opened public comment on the topic, saying he was “disheartened” that the city was debating when a Latino man could finish prepared remarks and called for the council to choose “healing over harm, compassion over technicality.” Several other speakers, including Mitra Engineer, David Tong (representing Beach Cities Alpha), Anya Goldstein and Jan Zucchi, described remarks at the Oct. 7 meeting that they said questioned the motives of speakers, mocked parents and discouraged youth participation.
Nancy Johns read a letter on behalf of Kelly Stewart that said a council member had used his position to air “personal and vindictive grievances” and compared recent comments to past instances in the city’s history involving discrimination. Several speakers said the treatment of young athletes and parents at the Oct. 7 meeting left teenagers disillusioned about civic participation.
Council members responded during the council‑comment portion of the Oct. 21 meeting. Mayor Bill Pimentel and others accepted responsibility for how some remarks were received. Council member Lance Giroux said his earlier comments had been directed at specific board members and apologized to parents and athletes who felt targeted, saying “I do apologize to the parents and the athletes who felt that any of that was aimed towards them.” Other council members thanked residents for engaging, emphasized the importance of public comment and said they would work to ensure respectful discourse going forward.
There was no formal disciplinary action or vote related to conduct at the Oct. 21 meeting; the item was raised as citizen comment and as part of council members’ remarks. Several speakers called for clearer acknowledgement from the council that Latino residents are valued and protected; council members said they had heard that request and would continue dialogue.
