Committee deadlocks on bill to allow live online firearm safety classes for concealed-carry permits

HB 2414, introduced by Delegate Oakes, would add an option to meet concealed-handgun permit training requirements through a live online safety or training class in which instructor and student can interact via video platforms.

The bill’s sponsor, Delegate Oakes, told the subcommittee that live online platforms such as Zoom and Teams have been used for years and would especially benefit residents in rural areas and people with limited mobility. “Platforms such as Zoom and Teams have been used for years now when an in person class is neither convenient nor available,” Oakes said.

Supporters, including Taylor McKee with the National Rifle Association and Phil Van Cleve of the Virginia Citizens Defense League, said the proposal would increase access for people who cannot readily reach an in-person instructor. “As our technology evolves, we think this could sufficiently supply training to folks who might be harder to get out there,” McKee said.

Opponents argued online instruction cannot substitute for in-person observation of handling and physical safety. Andrew Goddard of the Virginia Center for Public Safety said recent improvements to concealed-handgun permitting require in-person demonstration so examiners can “see a little bit about the person and they can be seen to handle a weapon and demonstrate their competence.” Christine Payne of the League of Women Voters of Virginia and Laurie Haas also testified in opposition, emphasizing that in-person training is needed to assess physical ability and handling.

The subcommittee voted on a motion to report HB 2414 to the full committee; the clerk recorded the motion failing on a 3–3 vote. The chair closed consideration of the bill afterward.

Votes at a glance: a motion to report HB 2414 failed 3–3.