Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Short Term Rentals topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Board of Adjustment approves 13 home‑sharing special exceptions with conditions
Summary
The Board of Adjustment approved 13 short‑term rental special exceptions across the city, generally limiting occupancy, adding quiet‑hour rules and banning on‑street parking during those hours; several residents opposed approvals citing neighborhood character and housing concerns.
The Board of Adjustment approved 13 special‑exception permits allowing home‑sharing (short‑term rental) activity at properties across the city on the condition that operators meet occupancy, parking and quiet‑hours limits.
The approvals, taken in a batch during the board's hearing, included limits such as quiet hours from 9 p.m. to 8 a.m., prohibitions on on‑street parking during quiet hours, vehicle caps and mostly one‑year initial terms. One permit, case number 16036, was approved for a three‑year term.
Why it matters: Residents and some board members said the conditions are intended to balance property owners’ ability to rent short‑term with neighborhood livability and enforcement needs. Protesters at one hearing urged the board to reject applications in the Plaza District and other long‑established neighborhoods, arguing that more short‑term rentals reduce long‑term housing supply and undermine neighborhood character.
Votes at a glance
- Case 16036 (John and Samantha Layden), 8600 S. Brookline Place — Approved. Modifications: three‑year term; quiet hours 9 p.m.–8 a.m.; 2‑car maximum; no on‑street parking during quiet hours. - Case 16040 (Pillar and Post Properties LLC), 8402 S. Douglas Ave. — Approved. Modifications recorded at approval: maximum 8 guests; quiet hours 9 p.m.–8 a.m.; 4‑car maximum; no on‑street parking during quiet hours; one‑year term. - Case 16041 (10313 Plymouth Court, applicant Lizette Alvarado) — Approved. Modifications: maximum 7 guests; quiet hours 9 p.m.–8 a.m.; no on‑street parking during quiet hours; 4 cars maximum (2 in garage, 2 in drive); one‑year term. - Case 16042 (Elite State Group LLC), 2036 NW Seventeenth St. — Approved. Modifications: maximum 7 guests; quiet hours 9 p.m.–8 a.m.; 4‑car maximum (2 in garage, 2 in driveway); no on‑street parking during quiet hours; one‑year term. - Case 16043 (Mark and Elizabeth Gillenbeck), 19727 SE 160th St. — Approved. Modifications: maximum 14 guests (applicant described bed layout to support this); quiet hours 9 p.m.–8 a.m.; 6‑car maximum; one‑year term (first‑time special exception). - Case 16044 (Alyssa Floyd / manager Tessa Dodson), 3413 NW 201st St. — Approved. Modifications: maximum 6 guests; quiet hours 9 p.m.–8 a.m.; 3‑car maximum; no on‑street parking during quiet hours; one‑year term. - Case 16045 (Colton Wade Haskin), 2531 NW 11th (duplex) — Approved. Modifications: each unit limited to 4 guests; quiet hours 9 p.m.–8 a.m.; 2‑car maximum; no on‑street parking during quiet hours; one‑year term. - Case 16046 (James Barnum), 218 NW 208th St. (Lehi Historic Landmark Overlay) — Approved. Modifications: maximum 8 guests; quiet hours 9 p.m.–8 a.m.; 3‑car maximum; no on‑street parking during quiet hours; one‑year term. - Case 16047 (James Barnum), 1344 SW Fort — Approved. Modifications: 2‑car maximum; quiet hours 9 p.m.–8 a.m.; no on‑street parking during quiet hours; driveway must be paved within one year (to be considered at renewal); one‑year term. - Case 16048 (Deanna M. Dixon), 2408 NW 115th — Approved. Modifications: maximum 7 guests; quiet hours 9 p.m.–8 a.m.; no on‑street parking during quiet hours; vehicle limits set consistent with garage/drive configuration; one‑year term. - Case 16049 (Vincent Wallace / representative Misty Stowe), 5901 N. Terry Ave. — Approved. Modifications: maximum 7 guests; quiet hours as listed in application (8 a.m.–8 p.m. was noted on application, board adjusted to 9 p.m.–8 a.m. in some cases); maximum 4 vehicles; no on‑street parking; one‑year term. - Case 16050 (Wiley Willingham), 413 Cricket Hollow (Edmond) — Approved. Modifications: maximum 5 guests; quiet hours 9 p.m.–8 a.m.; 2‑car maximum; no on‑street parking during quiet hours; one‑year term. - Case 16052 (Jacqueline Jones Holguin / Jacqueline Delone), 3204 SW 104th Terrace — Approved. Modifications: maximum 7 guests; quiet hours 9 p.m.–8 a.m.; no on‑street parking during quiet hours; vehicle limits set by garage/drive layout; one‑year term.
Public comment and enforcement
Neighbors spoke against several requests, most prominently at 2036 NW Seventeenth Street where multiple residents said a short‑term rental would “erode the neighborly feeling” on the block. Emily Casey, who identified herself as a homeowner on NW Seventeenth, said, “Allowing a short term rental would without a doubt erode the neighborly feeling that makes our street special.” Another resident, Wendy Millette, cited reporting on rising rental prices and said she worried approvals would “exacerbate the ongoing crisis of housing insecurity and homelessness in our city.”
Board members and staff told applicants to provide contact information to nearby residents and noted that renewals are subject to review; staff also encouraged neighbors to file code complaints through the city Action Center if operators do not follow conditions. A board member noted the city ordinance limits short‑term special exceptions to roughly 10% of available houses on a block — for a 23‑house block that was described as allowing up to two special exceptions.
Background and next steps
Most approvals were initial one‑year special exceptions, a common practice the board said to allow monitoring of operations and enforcement. Applicants seeking longer terms must return for timely renewal, and board members said renewal records and any complaint history will factor into those requests. No appeals were announced on the record at the close of the short‑term rental agenda items.
