Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Transportation topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Cave Creek USD confronts transportation staffing crisis; board approves CDL salary-compression changes
Summary
Interim transportation director described steep driver losses, extreme route times and aging buses. The governing board approved salary-compression adjustments intended to improve recruitment and retention.
The Cave Creek Unified School District governing board on Wednesday approved salary-compression adjustments aimed at relieving a critical shortage of commercial driver's-license (CDL) bus drivers after an extended presentation about safety risks, long route times and an aging fleet.
Interim Director of Transportation Linda Suter told the board the department has lost nearly 40% of its workforce in two years and is operating routes at more than full capacity. "These people give of their heart and soul every day to the kids in this community," Suter said, describing drivers who routinely cover high annual mileage and routes that now average about 62 minutes.
Why it matters: The district serves a geographically large attendance area; longer routes and fewer drivers increase safety and reliability risks for daily student transportation, and the shortage has already forced canceled or consolidated runs and longer student ride times.
The board heard detailed staffing figures and service impacts. Suter said the department has dropped from 48 employees in 2023–24 to far fewer today, including a reduction in full‑time CDL drivers from 24 to about 12 and a corresponding loss in support staff. She told the board several drivers were on extended leave and others were expected to depart, leaving the operation strained: "Logistically, it's just not real," she said of the mileage demands on remaining drivers.
District staff recommended structural changes to the salary schedule. Dr. Hendrickson (cabinet member) outlined a plan to move the district to "salary bands" for transportation employees so pay is tied to experience ranges instead of a single compressed scale. "It helps with retention," she said, adding that predictable pay bands can increase retention and recruitment.
Board members asked whether a one‑time stipend or other interim measures should be considered while the longer term compression correction is implemented. Trustees and staff discussed the limits of the district budget and the tradeoffs of mid‑year pay changes; Superintendent Phil Dolezal said the board retains discretion through the budget process and that any mid‑year decisions would have downstream fiscal consequences for carry‑forward and subsequent fiscal years.
Formal action: The board moved and passed a resolution approving the recommended salary adjustments to address CDL driver pay compression (Item 6.22). The motion passed by voice vote; no opposition was called on the record.
What comes next: Transportation leaders told the board their immediate hiring targets include five full‑time CDL drivers, three part‑time substitutes, two additional white‑fleet drivers and two bus aides. Staff said they will continue active recruiting, interview candidates daily and pursue short‑term supports such as substitute pools while they implement the salary‑band changes. The board asked staff to return with details on implementation steps and projected costs.
Ending: Trustees and staff framed the changes as only a first step toward stabilizing a department that district leaders described as operating beyond sustainable limits. "If we don't do anything, my fear is that we keep on the path of losing more employees," a cabinet member said.
