Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Window Replacement topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Board approves simulated check‑rail Fibrex inserts for windows at 232 North George Street
Summary
The HARB recommended approval for replacement windows at 232 North George Street using a spring‑line simulated check‑rail design in Fibrex composite inserted into existing frames to preserve exterior woodwork.
The York City Historical Architectural Review Board on Sept. 11 recommended approval of replacement windows at 232 North George Street that use a spring‑line (arched top) simulated check‑rail design installed as inserts into the existing frames.
Eric Bloom, representing Renewal by Andersen, told the board the property’s existing windows have an unusual geometry: the brick arch forms a curved exterior but the interior framing is square, and the top sash closes to a spring line. "So what we're doing is doing a spring line and then what's called a simulated check rail," Bloom said, adding that the replacement units will be inserted into the existing frames to keep original exterior woodwork intact. The proposed units use Fibrex composite that “looks like painted hardwood” and include fixed exterior grills and interior dividers between the glass to replicate the current appearance from the street.
Board members asked whether the frames would be retained (they were) and whether a double‑hung unit could be installed (Bloom said no, because of the brickwork and the way the sashes operate). The board indicated that preserving the visible exterior woodwork and matching the original sightlines and profiles were priorities. Board members confirmed that HARB acts as a recommending body and that City Council provides final approval for certificate/permit issues.
A motion to approve the application for the simulated check‑rail insert units in a composite material was moved, seconded and approved. Bloom was told he need not attend the council meeting unless City Council requests his presence; staff will forward HARB’s recommendation to the council packet.
The board’s guidance preserves the building’s visible historic character while allowing modern, more durable materials in the window units themselves.
