Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Public Participation topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Sullivan County Legislature adopts three-minute public-comment limit; residents press for fuller input
Summary
The Sullivan County Legislature narrowed public-comment time to three minutes and clarified meeting decorum; several residents and advocates told the Legislature the limit stifles public participation and urged action on housing and county care-center staffing.
The Sullivan County Legislature voted to adopt a three-minute time limit for public comment and a set of meeting-decorum rules, the body’s chair said at the start of the session. The chair told members she would read each resolution and then ask for a motion so the meeting pace would be slowed and orderly.
The new rules require speakers to be recognized by the chair, confine remarks to issues immediately before the body, limit members to two speaking turns on a motion, require remarks be addressed to the chair rather than to other legislators, and cap public comment at three minutes. The chair said the change was made “in the interest of time” because the Legislature has a heavy agenda and sometimes enters executive session for matters requiring later votes.
Public commenters pushed back during the meeting’s public-comment period. One resident said faster time limits undermine the First Amendment and asked the Legislature to restore longer slots for some commentators. Star Hesse told the Legislature the three-minute limit was an “insulting, disrespectful, and dismissive attempt to stifle information input from the public” and urged legislators to reconsider.
Other speakers used their comments to press the county to act on specific service issues. A commenter urged accelerated work on the Gateway Housing Project to reduce reliance on emergency shelter spending, arguing grants now available may not be available in the future. Another public commenter, representing a family council, said the care center’s new administrator had been cooperative but urged the county to begin a formal search for a director of nursing who meets New York State civil service requirements.
Legislators responded that the change in the public-comment limit was intended to keep business moving and that citizens’ concerns raised during comment would be taken under advisement. The chair also noted training on Robert’s Rules of Order would be scheduled and encouraged attendance.
The meeting record shows the Legislature repeatedly affirmed the new rules and proceeded into its agenda; no formal motion to rescind the public-comment limit was introduced during this session.
