Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Library Standards topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Department pauses adoption of new school library standards, urges districts to maintain challenge policies
Summary
The department told the board it has not adopted the proposed updated school library media standards and recommended retaining the 2008 handbook while work continues; staff also clarified the department no longer directly oversees public libraries and urged districts to ensure local challenge procedures are in place.
The Alabama State Department of Education reported to the board that it has delayed adopting a proposed update to the state's school library media standards and recommended continuing to rely on the 2008 handbook while the department and library professionals resolve concerns about external links and challenge procedures.
Department leaders said an updated standards document circulated by the librarian association contained web links and references to outside organizations that have changed over time; the department said it prefers standards that do not rely on external links because linked content can be revised or removed, producing inadvertent endorsements. "We went back to the librarians, that group of librarians, and with some changes to the document... My recommendation is that we stick with the 2008 standards because they're fine, and we just let it go at this point," the state superintendent said during the discussion.
Board members and staff also discussed policy and process for handling individual challenges to library materials. The department noted there is no state-level appeals process that overturns local board decisions on contested materials; instead, local school boards are expected to follow local challenge policies. The superintendent said the department could send a memo reminding districts to ensure that local policies exist and to clarify procedures for book fairs, library collections and public inquiries.
The department also clarified that oversight of public libraries is separate from the department's responsibilities for school libraries. Staff explained that an older statute mentioning the superintendent's role over public libraries is effectively obsolete and that the state's public-library system has a separate board and line-item appropriation in the state budget.
Board members requested the department send a reminder to superintendents and local boards asking them to confirm they have an up-to-date challenge policy and to provide guidance for handling public complaints; staff said they would prepare such a memo.
No formal policy change was adopted at the meeting; the department's working recommendation was to retain the 2008 school library media handbook for the time being while further review continues.
