Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Land Use Rezoning topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Rutherford planning commission approves Waldron rezoning for Valley View Road amid drainage concerns
Summary
The commission voted 9-1 to rezone about 19.7 acres along Valley View Road from agricultural-residential (AR) to residential medium (RM). Neighbors raised repeated flooding concerns; staff and the applicant said stormwater will be addressed at the next site-plan steps and the applicant agreed to hold a neighborhood meeting.
Rutherford County Regional Planning Commission on Aug. 11 recommended rezoning about 19.7 acres along Valley View Road from agricultural-residential to residential medium density, clearing the way for a conceptual extension of the Chestnut Valley subdivision.
The commission approved the rezoning request, REZ-25017 (Waldron Enterprises), by roll call, 9-1. The motion passed “with staff comments,” and commissioners said stormwater and design details will be reviewed during the required preliminary plan and construction-plan stages.
Residents who live adjacent to the site told the commission they regularly experience standing water and worry development will increase flooding. “I’ve got a $6,000 dike already around my home to keep it out,” said a neighbor who identified himself at the podium and said he has lived at his property for 30 years. Roxanna Sampson, 7620 Valley View Road, told commissioners the proposed subdivision would be “in my front yard” and said the loss of tree cover and increased housing could harm property values for longtime residents. Norbert Braunwalder, 7310 Valley View Road, said existing low spots and sinkholes hold water and asked how runoff from new streets and lawns would be handled.
Doug DeMasi, planning staff, told commissioners the property is currently zoned AR and that the applicant asked for RM to match surrounding parcels. DeMasi noted the submission was a concept plan only and not a binding site plan. He said staff had collected letters and photographs from neighbors documenting drainage problems and that county engineering staff would require engineered drainage plans during the preliminary-plan and construction-plan reviews.
A representative for the applicant, Rob Olsen, spoke on behalf of Waldron Enterprises and said the rezoning would allow residential lots smaller than 15,000 square feet similar to adjacent Chestnut Valley. Olsen said the applicant would work with county staff on required engineering.
County staff and the commission emphasized the limits of a rezoning review. Mike (county staff) and other engineers described the site as partly “karst” terrain with sinkholes and depressions that hold water. “By law, you evaluate what’s leaving the site now; you’re not supposed to increase anything that’s leaving the site,” staff told commissioners, noting the preliminary-plan and construction-plan steps will require detailed stormwater modeling and as-built surveys. Commissioners and staff discussed examples where oversized detention ponds and wetlands were used in other developments to reduce downstream flooding.
Commissioners debated whether the rezoning could be conditioned to require a developer-hosted neighborhood meeting to explain stormwater controls. Planning staff advised that rezoning approvals are not typically conditioned in that way for non-PD (planned development) rezonings, but the applicant’s representative committed at the hearing to arrange a neighborhood meeting with residents to go over the project’s preliminary plans and stormwater approach.
The commission approved the rezoning during roll call: Jeff Phillips (yes), Mike Kush (yes), Lee Vogel (yes), Charlotte P. (yes), Trey Gooch (yes), Jim Thompson (no), Michael Shirley (yes), Jason Beavers (yes), Amber Brown (yes), and Hettis Reed (yes). DeMasi said staff will continue to review engineered plans at the preliminary and construction stages and that maintenance of stormwater facilities would likely rest with a homeowners association with a county backstop agreement if the HOA fails.
Next steps: the developer must submit a preliminary plan that includes an overall drainage plan; construction drawings and an as-built survey will follow. The rezoning recommendation will be forwarded to the county commission at its scheduled public hearing, and staff and the applicant indicated they will hold additional neighborhood outreach and engineering coordination before the development returns for plan-level reviews.
Votes at a glance REZ-25017 (Waldron Enterprises) — Rezoning from AR to RM; commission recommendation: approved (9-1).
