Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Zoning Demolition topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Board grants conditional approval to demolish noncontributing house at 843 East Street pending rezoning
Summary
Madison Historic District Board of Review granted a conditional certificate of appropriateness to allow demolition at 843 East Street, contingent on successful rezoning to a commercial/industrial designation.
The Madison Historic District Board of Review voted to grant a conditional certificate of appropriateness for demolition of the noncontributing structure at 843 East Street, with the approval conditioned on completion of the applicant’s rezoning to commercial or industrial zoning.
Applicant Zach (representing the property owner) said the house sits adjacent to warehouse docks and the proposed demolition would improve truck access and turning movements for a nearby manufacturing operation. Board staff (Brenda) said the house is noncontributing and built circa 1919, and that demolition standards in the district discourage demolition as a first choice but allow consideration when zoning and functional needs justify the action.
Several board members expressed reluctance about tearing down an existing house, with one member saying the demolition “does not meet the guidelines” in a strictly residential zoning context. Other members stressed the economic importance of retaining and expanding manufacturing and favored a conditional approval tied to rezoning to avoid creating a precedent for demolitions while the lot remained residential.
Public comment included concerns about the adjacent property owner, nearby elderly neighbors and the potential visual and lighting impacts of a parking lot, and suggestions that the board condition approval on a privacy fence or lighting controls. A representative assisting the applicant asked the board to allow a conditional approval to avoid construction delay and potential winter schedule impacts.
After discussion, the board voted to grant a conditional certificate of appropriateness for demolition at 843 East Street to allow the applicant to proceed only if and when the property’s zoning is changed to permit the proposed parking/industrial use.
The board instructed staff to record findings of fact and to include documentation and salvage conditions as described in the design guidelines. The condition requires the applicant to complete the rezoning process before converting the lot to parking or other nonresidential use.
