Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Rule 13 Waiver topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Board denies waiver of six‑month waiting rule for 1 The Downs short‑term rental petition
Summary
The Zoning Board denied a request to waive Rule 13’s six‑month waiting period for a short‑term rental application at 1 The Downs, following strong neighborhood opposition and testimony describing personal safety and neighborhood preservation concerns.
The City of Tuscaloosa Zoning Board of Adjustments on Aug. 25 denied a petition to waive Rule 13’s six‑month waiting period so an applicant could immediately refile for a short‑term rental permit at 1 The Downs.
The petitioner, represented in part by property manager Kim Roberts, had requested the waiver to re‑present a previously denied application. Roberts told the board the owner hired a property management company after the prior hearing and that the manager would reduce guest counts and vehicle allowances recommended earlier.
Neighbors who spoke in opposition cited the neighborhood’s historic designation, traffic and noise concerns, and personal safety issues. Dr. Eric Lake, who identified himself as a disabled military veteran, described how frequent, unpredictable turnovers at a short‑term rental near his home would aggravate medical conditions and impede his ability to build predictable relationships with neighbors.
Neighbor Charter Morris said recent behavior by the owner — and a row of vehicles parked along the street — illustrated why the six‑month pause should remain in place so the owner could demonstrate substantive changes.
Board action: After public comment and board discussion, the ZBA voted to deny the waiver request. Several board members noted the applicant had been given opportunities at the prior hearing to accept staff recommendations (including lower occupancy and vehicle counts) and had declined.
Why it matters: Rule 13 exists to prevent rapid refilings after a denial and to permit applicants time to change circumstances materially. The board’s decision preserves that waiting period in this case and requires the owner to wait the prescribed interval before reapplying.
Ending: The denial closes the immediate route for the applicant to reapply for a special exception for 1 The Downs; the owner may return after the six‑month period if substantive changes are documented.
