Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Gift Disclosure topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Ethics commission: tickets purchased with city discretionary funds are gifts that may require disclosure; gala tickets for board delegates exempt
Summary
The Ethics Commission adopted a staff advisory opinion holding that event tickets purchased with a city commissioner’s discretionary office funds and kept for personal use are gifts that must be reported on the Form 9 if their combined value exceeds $100.
The Ethics Commission on (date not specified) adopted a staff advisory opinion about gift reporting when a city commissioner uses discretionary municipal funds to purchase sponsorships and obtains event tickets.
Lede/nut graf Staff concluded tickets obtained through a city’s discretionary office funds and then used personally by a commissioner are gifts under Florida Statute 112.312 and must be disclosed on the CE Form 9 if the combined value exceeds $100. The commission adopted the draft opinion by voice vote.
What staff recommended Amelia (staff attorney) explained the statutory definition of "gift" in Fla. Stat. 112.312(12)(a) includes "tickets to events, performances, or facilities" and that a purchase made with city funds is consideration provided by the city — not by the commissioner personally. "Because the sponsorship purchase is coming from the discretionary funds allotted to his office by the city, rather than from his personal funds, we do not view that as the commissioner providing consideration for the tickets," staff said. As a result, tickets retained for personal use become gifts to the commissioner and — if valued over $100 — must be disclosed on Form 9, listing the city as the donor.
Board‑service exception for a delegate Staff further advised that an exemption in Fla. Stat. 112.312(12)(b)(1) removes certain items from the definition of "gift" when they are "associated primarily with the donee's employment, business, or service as an officer or director of a corporation or organization." The opinion applied that exemption to the commissioner who serves as the city’s designated voting delegate on the Broward League of Cities board of directors and receives gala tickets intended for board members sworn in at the installation event. For that commissioner, staff concluded the tickets "appear to be a gift associated primarily with his service as a director of the Broward League of Cities" and need not be reported; other commissioners who receive tickets but are not board members must disclose them if the value threshold is met.
Questions and clarifications from commissioners Commissioners questioned whether the purchase and receipt are both "public capacity" actions and debated whether requiring disclosure in these narrow circumstances is an administrative wrinkle. Staff and general counsel explained the distinction: the city purchases tickets in a public capacity (city funds); if the commissioner keeps and uses tickets for personal attendance, that use is in a private capacity and therefore is a gift. Staff said the Form 9 should list the city as donor and the combined ticket value as the gift value. The commission also discussed whether alternates or backup delegates on an organization’s board would qualify for the b(1) exemption; staff advised alternates do not, because they are not serving as board directors.
Vote and next steps A motion to adopt the draft opinion passed by voice vote. Staff will finalize the advisory opinion and publish it with the guidance and the cited authorities, as well as circulate prior relevant opinions referenced in the draft.
