Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Historic District Designation topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Commission opens hearing and recommends West Avenues West historic district nomination
Summary
Staff presented a nomination for a large West Avenues West Historic District covering roughly the 2400–2600 blocks; the commission opened the public hearing, heard support and opposition, and made a recommendation in favor of designation.
The Historic Preservation Commission held a public hearing Monday on a nomination to permanently designate the West Avenues West Historic District, a large proposed district spanning roughly the 2400–2600 blocks of West Wisconsin, Wells, Kilbourn and State Streets.
Staff described the boundaries and the district’s period of significance (circa 1885–1931), noting 114 parcels that include Queen Anne, arts and crafts, neoclassical and Art Deco examples and multiple works by prominent Milwaukee architects. The report cited the district’s architectural diversity, examples of notable buildings (including the Kenmore and Cliff Court apartments, the Wisconsin Telephone Toll Building and the Milwaukee County Emergency Hospital / Dispensary) and the presence of individually listed and locally designated properties.
Public testimony included a broad mix: preservation advocates praised the district’s cohesive historical and architectural value; neighborhood residents and operators of affordable housing raised affordability and operational concerns for rooming houses and small multifamily properties included in the proposed boundary. Several speakers said the district could bring investment and protect building fabric; others said the map includes non‑contributing post‑World War II buildings and apartment properties where designation could create burdens. Staff noted that the nomination includes non‑contributing properties but that the district’s overall continuity and concentration of significant resources supports designation under multiple criteria.
After testimony, commission members discussed the scale and significance of the district and the role of subsequent zoning committee and Common Council review in weighing tradeoffs. The commission ultimately voted to recommend permanent designation (motion made and seconded; vote recorded as in favor) and will transmit the recommendation and the staff packet to the Zoning, Neighborhoods and Development Committee.
