Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the After The Fact Windows Roof topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Board approves after‑the‑fact window legalization with conditions, approves tile roof for Palm Grove house
Summary
The Miami Historic and Environmental Preservation Board approved an after‑the‑fact special certificate of appropriateness for replacement windows at a contributing Palm Grove house at 544 Northeast 70th Street, conditioned on completing building‑department legalization and installing historically appropriate muntins; the board also approved a replacement roof in S‑tile or barrel tile, color to match.
The Miami Historic and Environmental Preservation Board voted 5‑0 to grant an after‑the‑fact special certificate of appropriateness for replacement windows at 544 Northeast 70th Street in the Palm Grove Historic District, subject to conditions designed to restore the house’s historic appearance and to finalize permits. The board also approved a roof replacement using S‑tile or barrel tile in a color compatible with the house, and said applicants who seek asphalt shingles must file a separate economic‑hardship application.
Staff had recommended denial for the window and roofing package, saying the windows and proposed roofing would adversely affect the character of the 1936 contributing resource and did not comply with the Secretary of the Interior’s Standards and local historic guidelines. The owner’s daughter said the property’s windows were replaced without awareness of the permit requirements; the contractor had submitted but not finalized a permit.
The board discussed options to regularize work already done. Members emphasized the need for the owner to pursue the building‑department legalization process. The board’s approval required the owner to finalize the after‑the‑fact permit and to install muntins and mullions (raised‑profile muntins) as necessary to visually match historic windows; staff will approve details at permitting. On the roof, the board approved barrel or S‑tile to match historic photos and the house’s character, with color to be approved by staff; the board said an economic‑hardship letter and supporting evidence would be required for any request to accept asphalt shingles instead.
Why it matters: The action legalizes work already completed and sets clear remediation steps — legalization through the building department and visual compliance measures — protecting the Palm Grove district’s historic character while offering a path for the owner to retain recent investments.
Votes at a glance: Motion to approve after‑the‑fact SCOA for windows (with conditions) and to approve barrel or S‑tile roof (color to match) — passed 5‑0.
Provenance: Staff report describing lack of permit and nonconformance, public comments by owner’s daughter and applicant’s contractor, board debate on legalization and appropriate roof materials, motion and roll call vote.
