Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Municipal Procurement Parks Recreation topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
El Mirage council approves $180,000 Parks & Recreation admin remodel amid concerns over sole job-order contractor bid
Summary
The council voted 4–3 to authorize a contract with Woodruff Construction for a Parks & Recreation administrative-building refurbishment totaling $180,000; several members pressed for additional bids and questioned line-item costs.
The El Mirage Common Council approved a contract on June 17 to authorize the city manager to enter into a job-order contract with Woodruff Construction to refurbish the Parks and Recreation administrative building for $178,710.59 plus a $1,289.41 contingency, not to exceed $180,000. The motion passed 4–3.
Vice Mayor Parsons moved to approve the contract; Councilmember Winston seconded. Council members Norton McDaniel, Gentry and Eldridge voted no, producing a 4–3 outcome. The council discussion focused on procurement method and whether the job-order contract (JOC) process had produced competitive pricing.
Councilmember Gentry questioned specific line items and whether existing city space could be used instead of new construction. “When you're looking at paint and flooring, and we're spending $64,900 in paint and flooring alone, I can't see as knocking down anything in that area,” Gentry said, urging use of space in the senior center for a receptionist instead of adding remodel costs.
City staff responded that the senior center space referenced was actively used for programming, health-service outreach and storage and that locating a new management-support position away from the bulk of the department would reduce efficiency. Parks staff (identified in the meeting as Sean) said recent office renovations at the senior center had been intended to accommodate existing staff and programming use.
Multiple council members sought additional competition. “I think we need to get some other bids to get more competitive pricing and more realistic so that we don't have someone just taking advantage because they've already got it,” Norton McDaniel said after a site tour.
Councilmember Dorsey defended the JOC process and cautioned against restarting procurement for the project. “This process has been in place for a very, very long time,” Dorsey said. “There have been numerous projects that have been successfully built for reasonable costs in that time.”
City Manager Crystal said the job-order contract process is meant to streamline recurring mid-scale projects but acknowledged council concerns and said she would return with a work session on JOCs to review procurement strategy.
Why it matters: The vote authorizes immediate repairs and space reconfiguration for Parks & Recreation operations, but the split council revealed ongoing discomfort with using job-order contractors for midrange work without multiple competing bids.
Action taken: Council authorized entering a contract with Woodruff Construction as presented; the motion passed 4–3. No amendments to scope or budget were recorded at the meeting.
