Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Municipal Symbols Flags topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Motion to adopt City‑branded Pride and Juneteenth flags fails; commission to revisit flag policy later
Summary
A motion to adopt city‑branded Pride and Juneteenth flags as official city flags failed on roll call. Mayor Johnson and several commissioners said the choice of municipal government speech should remain for each two‑year commission and staff will bring an update to flag policy to the August legislative policy committee meeting
The City of Muskegon Commission considered a motion, carried over from a prior meeting, to designate city‑branded Pride and Juneteenth flags as alternative official city flags. After extended discussion the motion failed on a roll call vote.
Mayor Johnson explained his view that adopting city‑branded flags as "official" could bind future commissions to a specific government-speech choice and said that, absent a state-level constraint, the matter is better left to the discretion of each two‑year commission. "My thought is rather than us taking this action now to adopt these additional official flags and in some sense imposing our speech on future commissions, [we should] leave it to each commission," Johnson said.
Commissioners debated whether altering the flag policy or adopting branded flags would be necessary to insulate the city from potential legal challenges. City legal counsel advised the body that it could amend municipal policy to clarify which flags may be flown and that flying a flag as government speech is common municipal practice; the counsel also said the Juneteenth holiday has federal recognition but that a specific "federal Juneteenth flag" is not the same as the U.S. flag.
Commissioner Kilgo said he personally supports both flags but was reluctant to adopt them as official municipal flags at this time. Commissioner Cochin asked about the schedule for updating the city’s flag policy; Mayor Johnson and staff said an update will be considered at the August Legislative Policy Committee meeting. Commissioner German reiterated that the commission already had previously voted to fly the unbranded versions of the flags on specific occasions and that a no vote on the motion did not mean commissioners oppose flying the flags at all.
Roll call on the motion: vice mayor St. Clair — no; Mayor Johnson — no; Commissioner Kilgo — no; Commissioner German — no; Commissioner Gorman — no; Commissioner Kochen — no. The motion failed.
Why it matters: the debate framed legal and policy tradeoffs between preemptively adopting an official list of alternative flags and allowing each incoming commission to choose government-speech displays. Staff said they will propose revisions to the city flag policy for the legislative policy committee to consider in August.
