Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Cryptocurrency Regulation topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Committee advances disclosure bill for virtual tokens amid free‑speech and federal-regulation concerns
Summary
S.5473, a Comrie-sponsored bill that would require disclosures and regulate advertisements involving virtual tokens, was reported out of the Senate Banking Committee. Members and staff discussed First Amendment implications, the bill's relationship to federal securities rules, and called for clearer language or study.
The Senate Banking Committee reported out S.5473, sponsored by Senator Comrie, a bill to amend the Financial Services Law to require certain disclosures and to regulate advertising involving virtual tokens and similar products.
The committee's discussion focused on two tensions: how to prevent misleading commercial statements about virtual tokens while protecting open discussion and commentary, and whether state-level rules are premature where federal regulation remains unsettled. A committee member raised First Amendment concerns, saying the bill's language — which would bar statements that are "false" in advertising and other communications — could chill open discussion on local media or podcasts. That member said, "I'm a little more concerned about the open discussion around these. I think I understand the intent of the senator in this. He wants to make sure that there isn't misleading information that's being pushed out and that there's some accountability for people who are advertising for these," and added a worry that ordinary commentators could unknowingly make false statements.
Bobby Vardette, Senate Programming Council, described the bill as intended "to, sort of mirror federal anti touting, laws," noting a parallel with regulated communication rules for securitized products and explaining the proposal aims to provide disclosure where virtual tokens resemble regulated securities. Committee members also expressed concerns that the federal government has not yet established comprehensive regulation for crypto, leaving state legislatures to act without clear federal guidance.
One committee member said they would register an AWR on the bill and urged the sponsor to refine the language; the chair encouraged members to take their concerns directly to the sponsor for clarification. The committee then voted to report the bill out of committee; the transcript records the chair's announcement that the bill was "reported out," but no roll-call tally is recorded in the transcript.
