Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Land Use Concrete Crushing topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Conditional use permit for temporary concrete crushing draws wide neighborhood opposition; no council motion
Summary
A May 27 public hearing on a two-year conditional use permit for a concrete crushing operation near Jack Rabbit Run Golf Course and storage units drew multiple speakers citing dust, silica exposure, noise and traffic concerns; the matter died for lack of a motion.
A proposal to operate a temporary concrete-crushing site at 2678 Shady Bend Road drew extensive public comment at the Grand Island City Council’s May 27 meeting and ultimately received no motion for approval.
Tommy Emmel Jr., the property owner, said he purchased the M-2–zoned parcel about two years ago with the intent to use it for manufacturing/industrial purposes and had leased the site to Mid-Nebraska Land Developers. Robbie (surname given as RTS in transcript), speaking for the operator, described dust-control equipment (sprayers on conveyors, an internal sprinkler system inside an enclosed crusher), said the operation would limit crushing to about 40 tons per hour and said he would cease crushing on very windy days. Robbie said the crusher is internal and that he expected minimal noise from the crusher itself, though backup alarms and loader noise would be audible.
Multiple adjacent property owners and business representatives told council they opposed siting the operation at this location. Sedona Manful, general manager of Jack Rabbit Run Golf Course, said concrete dust contains respirable silica that can travel for long distances and harm turf and well water; she raised questions about the wind threshold that would stop crushing and who would be the contact if dust or noise problems occurred. Dennis Edwards and other neighbors described repeated dust and road-maintenance problems near the site and cited concerns about impacts to nearby houses, a new house under construction and the nearby storage business. Mike Shoemaker and other residents said they had observed dust clouds during windy conditions and expressed health concerns tied to silica exposure.
Planning staff presented recommended conditions that included limits on hours of operation and mufflers for equipment and noted the site is zoned M-2 (heavy manufacturing) where crushing is an allowable conditional use. The staff presentation noted similar long-standing crushing operations elsewhere in the city and identified distances to nearby sensitive uses (Gates Elementary School about 550 feet away; golf course about 660 feet away; nearest house about 600 feet).
After public comment, no council member moved to approve the conditional use permit; the mayor announced the matter died for lack of a motion. The council did not adopt conditions or modify the proposal in this meeting. Planning staff said the operator could pursue permitted uses consistent with M-2 zoning or return with a revised application.
