Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Municipal Operations topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Chino Hills council upholds ban on private decorations for city monument signs; motion passes 3-1
Summary
After staff warned of free-speech and liability problems with allowing private groups to decorate city-owned neighborhood monuments, the City Council voted 3-1 to continue prohibiting non-city installations on monument signs.
The Chino Hills City Council voted 3–1 on May 27 to keep in place a prohibition on private parties adding decorations to city-owned neighborhood monument signs.
City Manager Ben Montgomery told the council staff had evaluated four options after a homeowners association placed seasonal decorations on a monument at Alterra Park: (1) a permit process to allow private decorations on city property, (2) sell city monuments to private owners, (3) a city-run holiday decorations program, or (4) continue the current prohibition. Staff recommended the fourth option, citing legal and administrative difficulties.
Montgomery said a permit program would be difficult to administer and could raise free-speech issues because the city could not limit private use only to adjacent homeowners without exposing itself to equal-access or content-based challenges. Selling a portion of monument property, staff added, would require parceling and utility work that could be cost-prohibitive; a city-run decorations program would require up-front funding and decisions about which holidays to include.
Councilmember Cynthia Moran seconded the motion to continue the prohibition, and the motion passed 3–1; Councilmember Marquez voted no. Montgomery said staff will continue to enforce the current practice and field requests. The adopted policy keeps monuments available for their original public purpose and restricts non-city decorations on city property.
Ending: The council’s action formalizes the city’s longstanding approach and directs staff to maintain the existing prohibition rather than develop a permit program or sell monuments to private associations.
