Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Tree Mitigation topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Planning commission approves deferment of tree mitigation for Fulmer Farms, requires $63,000 security and adds neighbor‑focused amendment
Summary
The commission approved a deferred payment approach for tree mitigation on the Fulmer Farms Phase 1 & 2 grading/tree removal permit, requiring a $63,000 security and, by amendment, that 75% of any forfeited security be used to mitigate the site for nearby neighbors.
The Germantown Planning Commission on July 1 approved a staff‑recommended deferment of tree mitigation for Fulmer Farms Phase 1 and 2, allowing the developer to obtain a grading and tree removal permit while deferring the formal mitigation payment until final site plan review.
Staff said the grading and tree removal permit process (chapter 22 / vegetation ordinance) allows the applicant to prepare the site for future development while a final development plan is completed. Director Ross told the commission the developer’s tree survey produced a mitigation calculation of $63,000 ($47,000 for Parcel 1 and $16,000 for Parcel 2). Staff recommended the applicant post a letter of credit for that amount as a placeholder until the developer returns with a final plan; the letter of credit would allow the city — or the development contract process later — to fund mitigation if the project does not proceed.
Vice Chair Bacon moved approval of the deferment subject to staff conditions; the motion received a second and passed. Chairman McCreery offered and the commission approved an amendment — seconded by Alderman Salvaggio — to direct that if the security were ever called, at least 75% of the forfeited funds be used to mitigate the site directly (for the neighboring properties) rather than revert fully to a general fund. Commissioners voted unanimously on both the amendment and the final motion.
Developer representatives said the grading permit would allow site preparation during dry months and help market the property to medical users; they emphasized intent to preserve the on‑site pond and to coordinate with the Vineyard HOA on screening. The application area was annexed into Germantown in the 1970s; it was rezoned from residential to office in 2019. Staff explained changes to the city’s vegetation ordinance since 2019 and said the revised ordinance’s grading/tree‑removal pathway prompted the applicant’s request to clear the site ahead of a final plan.
Nearby resident and certified arborist Robert Jurgens urged stronger “do‑not‑disturb” buffer lines and expressed concern that some trees likely cannot survive the required fill and grading; he recommended larger buffers and adjustments to the detention basin to protect neighboring foundations. The developer and consultant said they had met multiple times with the Vineyards HOA, committed to continued coordination on plant species and placement, and said they will be on site during construction to manage neighbor concerns.
Staff clarified that the letter of credit will remain in place until the development contract and final plan process has been completed; if a final plan and development contract are not approved within 18 months, staff said the security could be used for mitigation as specified. The commission’s amendment clarifies that a large share of any forfeited funds should be applied to onsite mitigation or neighbor benefits.
Motion: approval of deferment of tree mitigation until final site plan for Fulmer Farms Phase 1 & 2, subject to staff conditions and posting of a letter of credit for $63,000 (staff recommended), amended to require at least 75% of forfeited security be used to mitigate the site for neighboring properties. Outcome: approved (unanimous).
