Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Zoning topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Council rejects expansion of Field House bar occupancy at 213 Ann Street
Summary
Council voted down a request to expand the Field House Sports Bar into adjacent space and reconfigure occupancy; opponents cited concentrated liquor establishments and noise impacts on nearby residents and senior housing.
The East Lansing City Council on Tuesday declined a request to modify the interior of 213 Ann Street to expand the Field House Sports Bar into adjacent Suite B with alcohol service and convert Suite C into a pizza shop without alcohol.
The application sought to maintain a combined building occupancy of 330 while redistributing seats among Suites A, B and C. Planning staff said the proposal would revert the commercial space configuration to a single primary bar/restaurant with an attached pizza operation and that Planning Commission and the DDA had previously recommended approval with conditions.
Several council members spoke against the request citing proximity to residents and “an undue concentration” of liquor establishments in the downtown. Council member Chris Altman said the downtown already contains many licensed establishments and expressed concern about night-time noise and residents’ quality of life, particularly for neighbors in the Newman Lofts. “I believe that their quality of life is affected negatively by this,” Altman said.
A motion to approve the special use permit was moved and seconded; the roll‑call vote was Altman — No; Meadows — No; Mayor Pro Tem Singh — Yes; Mayor Brookover — No. The motion failed.
City staff clarified the request would consolidate the commercial occupancy previously approved in 2012 and redistributed seats; applicant representatives described the request as a redistribution rather than an increase in the building’s total occupancy. Staff also noted earlier administrative approvals for portions of the property but said total occupancy remained capped at 330 under previous approvals.
Council members who opposed the request cited potential impacts on traffic, noise, public safety and the enjoyment of adjacent residences. Mayor Brookover and Council member Meadows each said they would vote against the permit because they believed the proposed use would have adverse effects on adjacent properties and would increase congestion and disturbances in the downtown. Mayor Pro Tem Singh supported approval, citing that the concerns were similar to challenges the city manages with other downtown businesses.
Because the motion failed, the applicant’s proposed expansion will not be authorized as presented; the applicant may revise the proposal and seek future consideration.
