Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Coastal Development Archaeology topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Commission declines to require new survey for after‑the‑fact coastal development permit, adds discovery clause
Summary
For Coastal Development Permit 2023-0022, the Archaeological Commission accepted an older survey, did not require new fieldwork and added an accidental discovery clause; the applicant argued decades of prior agricultural disturbance reduce the likelihood of intact resources.
The Mendocino County Archaeological Commission voted to accept prior archaeological work and impose an accidental discovery clause rather than require a new survey for Coastal Development Permit 2023-0022, an after‑the‑fact authorization that includes legalization of a second residential unit, on-site septic, grading, removal of a shipping container, and conversion of a barn to an art studio.
Applicant Scott Shadian described the property as the former Nichols Ranch, with “decades of intensive sustained mechanical and biological disruption” from dairy and agricultural uses. Shadian and his attorney-counsel argued that a 1976 survey found no significant resources and that case law and CEQA require substantial evidence of potential impacts to justify reopening a previously completed study. He cited case references during his remarks.
Planning staff and several commissioners acknowledged the earlier report and the site’s history of disturbance. Jesse Waldman of Mendocino County Planning and Building Services noted that a Northwest Information Center response letter—received after the initial packet—reported “some cultural material,” including one chipstone and a marine shell scatter, but that prior investigators had not identified a significant mapped site. The commission’s action was to accept the historical survey findings for permitting purposes and to add the standard accidental discovery clause.
Tribal and commission members debated when modern methods or the passage of time justify a new field survey. Valerie Stanley of the Sherwood Valley Tribe urged protection of cultural resources and offered to help arrange Northwest Information Center participation in a future discussion. Planning staff said they will attempt to invite Northwest Information Center staff to explain their review process.
No additional mitigation beyond the discovery clause was imposed at the hearing.
