Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Health Insurance Access topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Board hears warnings about abrupt Blue Shield–Meritage split that left members without providers
Summary
Retiree and employee representatives told the San Francisco Health Service Board that Blue Shield of California’s termination of Meritage Medical Group displaced roughly 924 members and left some without timely access to care; the board’s director said HSS is coordinating with Blue Shield and will post an FAQ.
The San Francisco Health Service Board heard repeated public accounts on May 20 of members left without expected care after Blue Shield of California ended its contract with Meritage Medical Group in Sonoma and Marin counties.
Public commenters and HSS staff said the termination displaced about 924 SFHSS members and that some received only a month’s notice to find new providers. “They were given 1 month's notice to find a doctor,” said an emergency-department nurse who identified herself as Katie, noting that Blue Shield customer-service staff told members to go to San Francisco or the East Bay or seek emergency care. “It is the absolute wrong thing to say to someone to go to the emergency department and burden those that staff and those patients that actually need emergency care.”
The board’s executive director, Ray Gillian, said at the meeting that Blue Shield reported the medical group’s contract termination was driven by financial concerns at Meritage and that HSS understands all members were assigned new providers, though some assignments did not occur until April 30. “A lot of members have experienced lack of access to care as well as confusion about the transition process,” Gillian said. He said HSS has been coordinating with Blue Shield, is seeing improved call-center response times, and planned to post a FAQ on the SFHSS website within days.
Several union and retiree representatives urged faster, clearer steps to reduce patient harm. Tracy McCray, president of the Police Officers Association, said members face canceled appointments and prescription interruptions and that emergency changes of coverage were in some cases quoted with high fees: “Some were told that that would be a $900 charge.” Fred Sanchez of Protect Our Benefits and Tim O’Brien of the Retired Firefighters and Spouses Association also described retirees losing previously available fitness and wellness options after prior carrier changes.
Board and staff responses focused on immediate member support and forthcoming information. Gillian said HSS was working with Blue Shield to sort through cases, that increased phone volume had strained HSS systems but that service had recently improved, and that staff would continue to provide direct assistance to affected members.
The matter surfaced again in later benefits discussions and rate presentations, and board members asked staff to prioritize outreach for members who faced interrupted specialty appointments or ongoing treatments.
The board did not take a formal vote on remedies at the meeting; instead, staff said it would publish guidance for members and continue coordination with Blue Shield.
