Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Procurement Fleet topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Boyle County discusses leasing vs. buying fleet vehicles; local dealers and fleet rep urge different approaches
Summary
County staff and two local dealerships discussed options for county vehicle acquisition, weighing outright purchases, closed-end leases and open-end programs. Dealers emphasized local service and the risks of open-end leases; a fleet representative described leasing benefits for low-mileage vehicles.
Boyle County Fiscal Court members and vehicle vendors spent an extended portion of the April 22 meeting exploring options for county vehicle procurement and fleet management. The court heard presentations from John Welsh of Bob Allen Fleet and from representatives of local dealerships who urged caution about certain lease structures.
John Welsh, representing Bob Allen Fleet, described leasing as appropriate for vehicles with low annual mileage and noted market-value swings that can make some lease outcomes favorable or unfavorable depending on used-vehicle pricing at lease termination. He warned that open-end leases carry risk at contract end if auction values fall below the forecast used to calculate payments.
"What they didn't tell you was that the vehicle may sell for less," Welsh said, explaining open-end leases where the lessee can be responsible for a shortfall after auction.
Local dealer representatives stressed local maintenance, pickup and delivery and community ties. A Powell dealership representative said dealers can match fleet pricing and provide local service and flexible ownership options, arguing that the county keeps economic value in the community when it buys locally.
Court members and staff asked for more information about the composition and age of the existing fleet, mileage profiles and repair costs for older vehicles. Finance staff and the court asked dealers to provide proposals tied to the county's current inventory and to outline closed-end lease options and local maintenance arrangements. The court did not vote on a procurement model at the meeting and asked staff to deliver fleet inventory and repair-cost details to the two dealerships that presented.
Ending: The court asked the vendors to return with specific, apples-to-apples proposals and directed staff to compile vehicle-age, mileage and repair-cost records for follow-up.
