Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Affordable Housing topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Commission approves Parcel H1A affordable building at India Basin with design exceptions; asks for softer facade palette
Summary
The Planning Commission unanimously granted major modifications to India Basin's design standards for a 179-unit, 100%-affordable building (Parcel H1A) after the sponsor requested relief from active-frontage and upper-floor stepback rules; commissioners asked for further façade and material refinements.
San Francisco ' The Planning Commission on May 1 approved major modifications to the India Basin Special Use District (SUD) design standards to allow a 100%-affordable building on Parcel H1A to deviate from several frontage and stepback standards, while directing the sponsor to refine materials and the color palette before final design sign-off.
The approved project is a six-story, 179-unit affordable housing building with retail, resident amenities and 137 vehicular parking spaces in a partially below-grade garage. The developer told staff the site's steep grade and programmatic constraints (transformer/electrical rooms, separate building lobbies for multiple cores and a required on-site drop-off for senior housing in the broader phase) led to longer stretches of non-active ground-level frontage than the India Basin DSG (Design Standards and Guidelines) anticipates.
Planning staff recommended approval of two major modifications (active frontage percentage and top-floor stepback) and one minor modification (commercial frontage length), concluding the proposed departures were consistent with the District's objectives and that the parcel's constraints justified limited exceptions. Staff noted the project would still provide substantial active frontage on the lane way and other street-facing facades, provide family-sized units and comply with required bicycle parking and other SUD standards.
Developers and the design team described the building as responding to the site's shoreline history with two material palettes, "seaside" and "landside," and noted constraints from utility placement and the economics of 100%-affordable construction; the sponsor said a seventh floor to allow a setback would push the building into a costlier construction type, jeopardizing feasibility.
Commissioners unanimously approved the major-modification requests but asked the sponsor to return with refined facade treatments and a lighter, less institutional color palette and to explore low-cost measures to visually enliven stretches of non-active frontage adjacent to transformer and utility spaces. Commissioner Braun moved approval with direction to continue to work with staff on final material selection and a differentiated datum at the top of the facade; the motion passed 7-0.
Why it matters: Parcel H1A is an early, publicly visible element of the India Basin mixed-use redevelopment and will deliver a sizable block of family-oriented affordable units. The commission's action acknowledges the tradeoffs between strict design-rule compliance and the practical and financial limits of building large 100%-affordable residential projects, while insisting on higher-quality visual treatment and enforceable conditions for the final facade and color decisions.
