Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Student Surveys Pace topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Pennridge board approves policy allowing third‑party student surveys, including PACE, after contested debate (5-3)
Summary
Trustees voted 5-3 to adopt policy 235.1 permitting third‑party student surveys with an opt‑out process; supporters said the PACE survey yields actionable mental‑health and substance‑use data, while opponents criticized parental‑consent provisions.
The Pennridge School District board adopted Policy 235.1, which allows the administration to authorize third‑party student surveys—including the Pennsylvania Youth Survey (PACE) cited by administrators—subject to an opt‑out process and administrative regulation, the board said in a 5‑3 roll‑call vote.
Supporters, including Superintendent Doctor Barrios and district staff member Mister Johnson, said the PACE instrument provides anonymous, school‑level data across four domains (community, school, mental health and substance use) that helps administrators, counselors and grant writers identify needs and tailor services. Johnson said features such as skip logic can limit exposure to sensitive questions and that students may skip individual items.
Opponents and several public commenters urged stronger parental protections, arguing that sensitive questions require prior written consent under the Federal Protection of Pupil Rights Act (PPRA) and Pennsylvania Code (22 Pa. Code §4.4). Commenters described specific questions they considered intrusive — on self‑harm, substance use and family relationships — and recommended an opt‑in approach or clearer advance notification of exact questions.
Administration said the PACE instrument is anonymous and that sample questions and administration plans would be posted in advance. The policy places survey implementation details in an administrative regulation and preserves parental opt‑out rights; administration said it would make sample questions available to parents before administration.
After public comment and trustee discussion, the board voted 5‑3 to adopt the policy. The meeting record shows that trustees debated whether the policy should be limited to the PACE survey or be broader to cover other third‑party instruments; trustees who voted for the policy emphasized the value of data for student supports while those opposed emphasized parental notice and consent processes.
The policy’s passage authorizes district staff to administer third‑party, anonymous surveys with the protections and procedures described in the adopted regulation; it does not mandate any immediate survey administration. Administration said it plans to provide parents advance access to sample questions if PACE is administered.
