Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the School Library Resources topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Board approves library purchases but pulls one high‑school title for further review
Summary
The Pine‑Richland board approved most recommended library purchases April 21 but voted to remove one high‑school title from the list for additional review after concerns about content and a vendor flag from the Junior Library Guild.
At the April 21 meeting the Pine‑Richland School Board approved the purchase of the librarians’ recommended titles but amended the motion to remove one high‑school title listed as "BOG wife" from the high‑school list for further review.
Board member Mrs. Bursales moved to amend the purchase motion to pull that single title for additional review; the motion to amend passed and the board approved the remaining list. The board discussion focused on why the title had been flagged by the Junior Library Guild and whether the district’s review process had adequately vetted the book.
Mrs. Bursales described that the high‑school librarian and principal had done an initial internal review, including a brief check of the vendor notes, and later advised the administration that their further review had concluded the title was appropriate to recommend. The board member said the librarians later pulled the title to look more closely after questions raised by another board member, and asked for more time to confirm the book’s suitability.
Curriculum‑area staff noted that most recommended titles go forward without issue and that librarians and principals follow a multi‑step review process. Doctor Pasquinelli (staff) told the board evaluators had considered alternative, free online resources in past reviews and that quality varies among open‑source options.
Board members debated process details: how the Junior Library Guild’s content flags are defined, what the local review included, and whether the district should read the full text before final approval. Administrators said the relevant building staff had "flipped through" the book and reported a preliminary check; the board approved holding the item for further review to allow a fuller evaluation.
The amended motion passed by voice vote; all other titles on the librarians’ list were approved. The board recorded that the administrative regulation and policy changes related to library resources (AR 1091 and AR attachments) were approved earlier in the meeting on a single‑reading motion. The pulled title may return to a future agenda after the building staff completes a fuller review and shares findings with the board.
Ending — District staff said the library list will proceed minus the pulled title and that administrators will report back once the targeted review of that title is complete.
