Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the School Policy topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
High-school teachers urge delay to stricter phone ban; board sends phone policy back to committee
Summary
A BEA-led high-school organizing team asked the Board to delay adopting a stricter district phone ban so building staff can implement a school-led plan; the board voted 4-2 to send the proposed policy back to the policy committee for further work.
Beloit Memorial High School teachers and an organizing team representing the Beloit Education Association urged the Beloit School District Board of Education on Aug. 5 to delay adopting a districtwide tightening of the student cellphone policy and allow building staff to test an implementation plan.
"We appreciate that the board wants to see the distractions of phones removed from the classroom," Becky (BEA high school organizing team) told the board during public comment, "but our concern is that the proposed policy change would make enforcement more difficult." The BEA speakers said their building has drafted a plan that would require students to store phones in a secure location at the start of each class period, and that a blanket daylong ban could push students to use lockers or bathroom passes and increase lost instructional time.
Board members debated the proposed change during the policy-item discussion. Supporters of the stricter rule—including board member Brian Nichols, who sponsored the policy changes—argued other districts' experience shows improved focus and reduced conflict when phones are restricted. Opponents and some teachers said enforcement and family burden concerns required more groundwork and a building-level pilot.
After discussion the board voted 4-2 to refer the proposed revision of Policy 443.5 (student use of mobile phones and electronic devices) back to the policy committee for further work. Roll-call votes recorded: Joanne Rue — aye; Brian Nichols — nay; Tom Hankins — nay; Amy Levy — aye; Juan Romero — aye; Tia Johnson — aye.
Why it matters: The policy governs in-school student access to phones and affects teachers' classroom management. The BEA organizing team said a uniform, building-based implementation at Beloit Memorial would be easier for staff to enforce and would allow for review before districtwide policy changes. The policy committee will revisit the language and enforcement protocols and report back as part of its normal cycle.
Next steps: The policy committee will meet with BEA and building leaders to review the proposed policy language and the building-level implementation plan before returning a revised recommendation to the full board.
