Council split over $3 million repair or $15.9 million overhaul for Island Oasis water park

Parks staff presented two alternative plans for Island Oasis on Aug. 21: a lower-cost package of repairs estimated at about $3 million and a comprehensive renovation priced at approximately $15.9 million.

A parks staff member described the $3 million option as primarily "pumps and filters" and repairs to extend the life of the existing facility. The larger $15.9 million plan would replace much of the facility, separate the wave pool and leisure pool, add a dedicated children's splash area, a miniature golf course and other attractions designed to increase family use and extend the season.

Council members and staff debated whether the larger renovation would generate enough additional visitation to justify the difference. One councilor noted the incremental cost difference of roughly $12.9 million and asked whether that spending would produce a commensurate increase in users over 20 years. Parks staff said the master plan included market analysis and that the full renovation was designed as a "destination" change to attract more families and extend hours; the staff presentation said the renovation would enable longer-season use and add revenue-generating features.

Several council members proposed financing options: bonding the project to spread cost over time, or staging work across multiple years. Others favored the smaller repair-only option now and suggested adding attractions such as indoor miniature golf or simulators later to extend off-season use.

Why it matters: Island Oasis is a major parks asset with high visibility. The council must weigh capital cost, potential revenue, seasonal-use changes and equity across other capital priorities when deciding a path.

Ending: Councilors asked staff for more detailed market projections, revenue estimates and bonding scenarios before taking a position on a preferred option.