Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Immigration Criminal Law topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
House panel advances bill creating human-smuggling and harboring offenses; critics warn of civil‑federal conflicts
Summary
Committee approved a bill creating crimes for aggravated human smuggling and for harboring people unlawfully in the U.S.; opponents said the measure is vague and could criminalize ordinary assistance and conflict with federal law.
A House Judiciary committee voted to send House Bill 3-22 to Finance, advancing legislation that creates a new human‑smuggling offense and a misdemeanor harboring offense for people who knowingly harbor or hide an individual unlawfully present in the United States.
Sponsor Representative Todd said the bill aims to distinguish human smuggling — transporting people across borders for commercial advantage — from trafficking and to create a separate offense for harboring or hiding individuals who have entered or remained unlawfully. The bill also contains an aggravated human‑smuggling provision punishable as a Class A felony when the victim is under 13, and a Class A misdemeanor for harboring that carries a $1,000 fine per person harbored.
During extended testimony, immigration‑advocacy witnesses and family members said the bill is overbroad and could turn routine acts of assistance into crimes. Johanna Cohen described church members sheltering a young woman from El Salvador and said the bill “would criminalize” helping families. Witness Ashley Warbington, who said her husband is undocumented, asked whether driving a spouse to a medical appointment or translating at a school could be charged under the bill. Legal counsel to the committee said the bill’s exemptions apply to attorneys licensed in Tennessee and to health‑care services provided at licensed facilities; those protections do not extend to out‑of‑state attorneys or informal assistance outside a licensed clinical setting.
Committee counsel clarified penalties and said aggravated smuggling would be a felony; harboring would be a misdemeanor punishable by a $1,000 fine per person harbored. Counsel also said whether longstanding marital privilege or other defenses apply would be fact dependent.
Supporters argued the bill focuses on harboring for commercial advantage and does not target temporary shelter, food or ordinary assistance without intent to conceal. Opponents countered that federal immigration enforcement is the prerogative of the federal government and that state criminal laws in other states adopting similar approaches have faced legal challenges and expensive litigation.
After public testimony and questioning of legal counsel, the committee approved the bill and sent House Bill 3-22 as amended to Finance, with a committee vote recorded 16–6.
