Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Site Plan Valvoline topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Planning Commission OKs Valvoline site plan, grants waiver for corner bay doors
Summary
The Planning Commission approved a 2,088-square-foot Valvoline oil-change facility at 258 East Main Street, granting a waiver for overhead bay doors that face the adjacent street and approving landscaping and staff conditions, after commissioners raised concerns about visual screening and traffic.
The Planning Commission voted to approve a site plan for a Valvoline oil-change facility at 258 East Main Street and granted a waiver for three overhead bay doors that face the adjacent street.
Assistant Planning Director Timothy Witten told the commission the lot is 0.7 acres and the proposed building is a 2,088-square-foot oil-change facility within the Mayfair Planned Development. "7 parking spaces are required, and they're providing 17," Witten said, noting the use is allowed in the plan development and that the applicant had agreed to staff comments.
Representatives for the project said the bays face a secondary street because the corner lot has drive-through access on both sides. Luke Clauser, the project engineer, and Michael Leverton, Valvoline's project manager, described operational expectations. "Service for an oil change only takes just under 15 minutes," Leverton said, adding the store would likely average "60 to 70 oil changes per day" with peak hours of about "12 to 15 oil changes in the hour." He said stacking typically would involve about two vehicles in the queue during peak times.
Commissioners pressed the applicant on visual screening and traffic. Commissioner Wendy Slattery said she opposed using waivers in this corridor and asked whether the landscaping would effectively screen the overhead doors. "Waivers are an abuse of our zoning," Slattery said, and later questioned whether common plantings would sufficiently hide the three large bay doors as drivers approach Main Street.
Valvoline's team said they were working with staff to increase both the variety and density of plantings, add taller evergreens and a landscape wall on the east side, and use higher-quality bay doors to improve appearance. The applicant acknowledged bay-door operation is weather-dependent and would be closed in adverse conditions, but open in mild weather.
A commissioner asked whether any city ordinance requires bay doors to be closed during service; staff answered no. After discussion the commission voted to approve the site plan "with all staff comments" and to grant the requested waiver. The motion passed with seven votes in favor and one opposed.
The approval allows the developer and Valvoline to move forward with permitting and construction steps that follow site-plan approval and staff conditions. Commissioners and staff noted they will continue to work with the applicant on final landscaping and screening details as part of permit review.
A summary of the formal action: the commission approved the Valvoline Mayfair site plan, accepted staff comments and granted the waiver for bay-door orientation; the vote was recorded as 7–1 in favor.
