Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Outdoor Dining topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
CB2 debates outdoor dining rules, FDNY waivers and a 10 p.m. time limit for new roadbed seating
Summary
Manhattan CB2 committees described a wave of new outdoor dining applications, concerns about FDNY waiver transparency and a committee practice asking new roadway seating to close at 10 p.m. to speed approvals through the State Liquor Authority.
Landmark, SLA and licensing committee members told the executive committee that applications for outdoor dining and roadway cafes have surged and that many applicants are seeking DOT or FDNY waivers.
Donna and other committee members reported that Community District 2 has seen an uptick in roadway cafe submissions and that the board has tallied more than 90 FDNY waiver requests in the district. Committee chairs said the FDNY process is not transparent: FDNY provides "letters of no objection" that sometimes record reservations but nevertheless permit DOT to issue waivers.
SLA representatives and committee chairs told the executive committee the board is broadly asking applicants that had no prior outdoor seating to accept a 10 p.m. closing time for new outdoor spaces. Committees said when applicants agree to a 10 p.m. closing the applicant can be processed more quickly by the board and the SLA; if the board opposes an application the applicant generally cannot serve alcohol outdoors until it is scheduled for SLA full board review, a process that can take months.
Speakers described safety and operational concerns: committee members said some roadway cafes use heavy modular or shipping‑container style structures and questioned whether waivers and battalion chief walk‑throughs adequately address emergency access on narrow streets. Committee members said the waiver process and communications from FDNY have been inconsistent and that residents have raised quality‑of‑life concerns about late hours near housing.
The Landmark committee reported large numbers of new applications in Soho and Bleecker Street corridors, including temporary decorative structures and illuminated display screens that the committee finds objectionable in historic districts. SLA committees reported dozens of pending applications and flagged several contested licenses, including a beer‑and‑wine application for 55 —/2 Green Street (submitted as 470 Broom) that drew broad neighborhood opposition.
Committee leaders said their approach is to expedite opening while asking initial limits so the community can assess impacts and businesses can later apply to adjust hours after a period of operation.
