Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Appointments topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Board appoints David Chu to San Francisco's seat on Bay Conservation and Development Commission after contentious seniority dispute
Summary
After lengthy debate over seniority and board rules, the Board of Supervisors appointed David Chu to the San Francisco Bay Conservation and Development Commission by a 7-2 vote; an earlier motion to appoint another supervisor failed.
The Board of Supervisors appointed President David Chu to fill San Francisco's seat on the San Francisco Bay Conservation and Development Commission (BCDC) after an extended floor dispute over seniority rules and the board's procedures (item 25).
Background: Two competing interpretations of board rules and state law led to an extended debate over who the board should nominate. Some supervisors argued the board's established seniority procedures should govern the selection; others said state law and the city charter give the full board discretion. The rules committee had considered the appointment and recommended action; disagreement in committee led the full board to address the matter on the floor.
Floor actions and votes: An initial motion to appoint another supervisor (Supervisor Ellsberg) failed by a 4-5 tally on a first motion. A later motion to appoint David Chu passed by roll call vote, 7 ayes and 2 noes; 2 supervisors were excused for part of the consideration but final roll calls are recorded in the transcript. Following board procedure and advice from the deputy city attorney, the board also handled recusals for nominated supervisors when appropriate.
Why it matters: BCDC is the multi-jurisdictional regional agency that oversees shoreline land use and the public trust along the Bay. Board representation at BCDC affects San Francisco's voice in regional shoreline planning and major projects affecting the waterfront and sea-level-rise policy.
Debate highlights: Several supervisors warned that overriding board traditions on seniority risks harming institutional norms; others emphasized that state law and the charter empower the board as a whole to select representatives. The choice and the maneuvering drew sustained discussion about the proper balance between written rules and discretionary appointment power.
Action details: Motion to appoint David Chu to an indefinite term to the Bay Conservation and Development Commission passed (7 ayes, 2 noes). The board also instructed the clerk to manage procedural steps and recusals per the city attorney's guidance.
