Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Education Textbooks topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Tipton County Board adopts state-recommended science textbooks, issues resolution criticizing content
Summary
At its regular meeting the Tipton County Board of Education approved the state-recommended science textbooks required by Tennessee standards and simultaneously passed a formal resolution saying the board disagrees with aspects of the materials and will seek state-level change.
The Tipton County Board of Education voted to adopt the state-recommended science textbooks and then passed a resolution registering the board's objections to portions of those materials.
Board members said they were constrained by state rules requiring adoption of state-approved materials but said the books contain statements they consider presented as fact rather than as debated theory. The resolution, prepared after prior work-session review, asks the board to notify parents, encourage teachers to present supplemental materials for balance, establish procedures for parental review and to advocate at the state level for changes to standards and textbooks.
The board discussed concerns including how evolution and climate change are presented, and passages the board described as stating conjecture or contested scientific claims as settled fact. The board chair said the district's hands were tied by state standards and the state textbook approval process but argued the board must put teachers and students "something to teach from" while registering its objections in a public resolution. Dr. Byrd and other board members repeatedly affirmed support for teachers while indicating they disagreed with the instructional content mandated by the state.
Board members debated whether to adopt the textbooks and then present the resolution or vice versa; after discussion they adopted the textbooks (as required by law) and then approved the resolution expressing opposition. One board member voted "no" on adoption; the motion carried. The resolution will be sent to the Tennessee Commissioner of Education and the State Board of Education, and the board directed staff to make the resolution available for parents and the community.
The board also asked for targeted follow-up: identifying specific state standards the board finds objectionable and coordinating outreach to the district's legislative representatives. No changes to classroom practice were ordered beyond the resolution's request that teachers may use supplemental materials to provide additional perspectives where appropriate.
The board's action acknowledges the legal requirement to adopt state-approved materials while documenting the board's formal disagreement and intent to pursue state-level change.
