Commission asks Surf/Art Hall of Fame back with nonprofit structure, urges alternate locations and clearer plan

Rick Petrie, a long-time San Clemente resident and former surf-industry professional, presented an unsolicited proposal to create a San Clemente Surf State Art and Music Hall of Fame honoring local surfers, skaters, artists and musicians.

Petrite told the commission San Clemente has produced high-level surfers and cultural contributors and argued a recognition program could promote the city and honor local ambassadors. "We have the number 1 city in the world for producing world class surfers and world tour surfers," he said, describing surfers, skateboarders and musicians tied to San Clemente.

Staff and commissioners discussed use of public property, long-term maintenance, existing city recognition programs and appropriate locations. Samantha Wiley noted the city already administers a community Wall of Recognition at the community center and a Sports Wall of Fame at Vista Hermosa Sports Park (managed by the Friends Parks and Rec Foundation) and said an unsolicited program placed on public property requires careful consideration of sustainability, administration and city responsibilities if an outside group later dissolves.

Commissioners raised concerns about siting on Del Mar Street or the pier, potential impacts to historic fabric and walkability, and long-term maintenance responsibility. Multiple commissioners suggested alternative approaches: tiles or plaques in publicly managed planters, locating honors near activity-related sites (for example, surf recognition near T Street), or placing elements along El Camino Real. Several commissioners said they did not want to commit to Pier property because the pier is undergoing planned work and prior pier damage had occurred.

Motion and direction: the commission unanimously passed a motion asking the proponent to return with a more defined proposal after establishing a nonprofit entity with bylaws, a mission statement, a board and a written plan of action that addresses criteria for selection, siting and long-term maintenance. Staff will also refer the concept to the Arts and Culture Committee for additional input before the item goes to city council.

Ending: The commission endorsed the concept in principle but required a nonprofit organizational structure and clearer site, design and maintenance plans before asking the city to consider any installations on public property.