Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Boards Commissions Appointments topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Council ratifies most board appointments; library seat removed after split vote
Summary
Council adopted appointments to several advisory bodies but a substitute motion removed one recommended library appointee, leaving the mayor and mayor pro tem to revisit the vacant seat. The decision drew public comment praising long‑time trustee candidates and raised questions about residents' representation.
The Carmel‑by‑the‑Sea City Council ratified a slate of appointments to city boards and commissions on Monday but declined to ratify one recommended library trustee after a 3‑2 split vote.
Staff reported that the city received 17 applications for multiple openings and that the mayor and mayor pro tem interviewed candidates before submitting a recommended slate. The council considered Resolution 2025‑051 to ratify appointments to the Community Activities Commission, Harrison Memorial Library Board of Trustees, Historic Resources Board and the Forest and Beach Commission.
Council debate focused on the Harrison Memorial Library appointment of Billy Farina, a recommended candidate who lives in the city’s sphere of influence rather than inside city limits. One council member argued the commissions should be a “bench” to prepare future council members and preferred to appoint new faces; another council member pressed that long‑standing local volunteers, including John Krisscher, had deep institutional knowledge and deserved reappointment.
After discussion the council considered and adopted a substitute motion that approved the full slate except for the appointment of Billy Farina to the Library Board. The substitute motion passed 3–2 on a roll call vote; the minutes record votes as follows: Council member Barron — yes; Council member Bueter — yes; Mayor Pro Tem Delves — no; Council member Dramoff — yes; Mayor Byrne — no. The council then directed the mayor and mayor pro tem to consider whether to repost the seat for additional interviews or bring back an alternative candidate at a future meeting.
Public comment included praise for long‑time volunteer service from residents who asked the council to reconsider incumbents denied reappointment. Nova (staff) confirmed that most recommended appointees live within city limits and said the applicants who live in the city’s sphere of influence include Gerald Montmorency, Billy Farina and Philip Pardue; she noted everyone else lives in the city limits.
What happens next: Because the substitute motion removed the Farina appointment, the council left an open seat on the Library Board to be reconsidered by the mayor and mayor pro tem at a future meeting or reposted for additional interviews. The council asked staff to bring back language and a resolution if the mayor chooses a replacement candidate.
