Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Zoning topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Council approves zoning change to limit return to abandoned nonconforming uses, overriding objections from two members
Summary
Council passed an amendment to Section 14-305 of the Philadelphia Code tightening rules on nonconforming uses. The bill prevents property owners who change a use without a required zoning permit from automatically reverting to a prior, grandfathered use; the final vote was 15–2.
Philadelphia City Council on March 20 passed an ordinance (Bill 240427) amending the city's nonconformity rules to restrict the ability of property owners to revert to a previously grandfathered use if they abandoned it without first obtaining required zoning permits.
Councilmember Jeffrey J. Young (Fifth District), who sponsored the bill, said the change is aimed at “prevent[ing] bad actors from returning to a use that they have already abandoned.” Young described the measure as a protection for neighborhoods that lose control when a property changes use without proper permitting.
Why it matters: The ordinance modifies Section 14-305 of the Philadelphia Code to clarify that properties that changed use without the legally required zoning permit cannot later claim the protections of a grandfathered use by right. Supporters said this closes a loophole that allowed properties to circumvent community review and the zoning process.
Debate and votes: Councilmember Young said he and stakeholders had worked with the Planning Commission but moved forward after waiting on broader code revisions. Councilmembers worked to exempt specific districts that raised concerns; nonetheless the final roll call recorded 15 ayes and 2 nays. The chief clerk read the roll; the clerk announced: “The ayes are 15. The nays are 2. Majority of all members having voted in the affirmative, the bill passes.”
Implementation and next steps: The change takes effect upon enactment as an amendment to the zoning code; the administration and the Planning Commission will implement the revised application review procedures. Councilmembers noted they had coordinated with stakeholders and industry representatives to limit unintended consequences for lawful property owners.
Ending: Supporters framed the vote as a neighborhood-protection measure that restores the community's ability to object to retroactive changes by property owners who bypass permitting requirements.
