Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Tax Cancellations topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Kootenai commissioners deny retroactive tax cancellation for lakeside parcel, advise hardship process
Summary
Kootenai County commissioners denied a property-owner request to cancel prior years' taxes for a lakeside parcel ruled nonbuildable, saying the board lacked a statutory basis for retroactive cancellation and directing the owner to pursue a hardship application under Idaho Code 63-711.
The Kootenai County Board of Commissioners on March 12 denied a request from Dave and Debbie Ventures LLC to cancel taxes retroactively for a lakeside parcel the owner says was declared nonbuildable, while allowing the owner to pursue a hardship cancellation under state law.
The decision came after several county officials and the property owner described access and permitting problems that the owner said sharply reduced the property's value. Commissioners Eberlein, Duncan and Matari denied the request "without prejudice," meaning the owner may later apply for an undue-hardship cancellation under Idaho Code 63-711.
County Assessor Kovacs told the board the assessor's office had adjusted the parcel's value for 2025 but that retroactive cancellations for prior years are governed by the board's discretion and limited by statute. "When the property owner has made the property tax payment, it's rather difficult to argue retroactively that it is a hardship and that those taxes should be canceled retroactively when that payment has already been made," Kovacs said.
County counsel and deputy prosecutors advised the board that tax cancellations after the fact are narrowly defined under state law. "Cancellation of taxes after that fact is very specific to hardship, casualty loss, or a mistake or double payment of taxes," County counsel Dave Ferguson said, urging the board not to use the cancellation process as a second avenue to challenge prior valuations that should have gone to the Board of Equalization.
The property owner described the on-the-ground problem: a 10-foot-wide strip of shoreline the owner said is part of the parcel but inaccessible by land because of historic highway easements and right-of-way changes. The owner also said the county fire marshal later declared the lots unbuildable and that he has incurred substantial housing costs since the permit issue arose. "Now I've been paying almost $50,000 worth of rent since this became unbuildable. That to me is a hardship," the owner said.
Legal staff and the assessor told the board there are multiple statutory paths depending on circumstances: cancellations for mistakes or double payments, casualty-loss cancellations, or hardship cancellations under Idaho Code 63-711. The board agreed the owner could pursue a hardship cancellation, and staff identified a hardship process contact (Terry Johnston) in the assessor's office for next steps.
The board's final motion denied the request to cancel past taxes for the parcel (AIN 224829) but left the owner free to apply for relief under Idaho Code 63-711. The motion passed.
Votes at a glance (actions taken during the meeting): - Denied request to reinstate 2022 timber exemption, AIN 253885 (motion passed). - Approved casualty-loss valuation reductions and interest/penalty waivers for AIN 188354 (reductions documented for 2022, 2023 and 2024; motions passed). - Denied Dave and Debbie Ventures LLC request for retroactive cancellation for AIN 224829; denial without prejudice to apply under Idaho Code 63-711 (motion passed). - Approved valuation adjustment (deactivation) for mobile-home AIN 116369, amending value to zero retroactively (motion passed). - Approved removal of incomplete-structure value for AIN 341004 (motion passed). - Approved several homeowner-exemption corrections and directed application of House Bill HTR credits where the assessor received timely applications (AINs: 258649, 321615, 165527, 125862, 118602; motions passed).
The board advised the property owner to pursue the formal hardship cancellation process in the assessor's office if he wished to seek retroactive relief. Staff said the assessor's office already adjusted the parcel's 2025 value and that appeals of market valuation for prior years should generally go to the Board of Equalization or the State Board of Tax Appeals.
Kootenai County staff also said they will follow up internally to avoid future delays in processing homeowner-exemption paperwork and to calculate homeowner tax-relief (HTR) credits where applications were submitted before the statutory deadlines.
The meeting record includes detailed motions and AIN numbers for each vote taken. The board adjourned after completing the scheduled adjustments and exemptions.
